Is Climate an Environmental Stressor for Conflicts?

  Focus - Allegati
  04 maggio 2022
  9 minuti, 29 secondi

Abstract:

Although considered as one of the greatest environmental challenges of the twenty-first century, climate change also represents an indirect pathway to feed political, economic, and social tensions. Extreme weather events, water shortages and food scarcity are likely to jeopardize geopolitical stability and to provoke health constraints, inequality, human migration and eventually wars. Thus far, the state of research on the implications that climate change may have on conflicts is still developing. The aim of this analysis is to provide a synthesized picture of the existing literature to prove the existence of an effective cause and effect relationship between climate change and conflicts.

Emerging Environmental Stressors:

Over the course of thousands of years, climate on earth has changed naturally several times. However, in the last decade there has been an acceleration in this trend, with global average temperature rising quickly above pre-industrial levels. What further concerns is the fact that climate change is not only an environmental issue. Under specific circumstances, environmental stressors can even disrupt peace and security. Clearly, changing weather patterns do not directly cause conflicts, rather they compound existing risk factors which eventually increase geopolitical instability. It is not coincidence that the most vulnerable countries to this threat are also those more vulnerable to conflict and fragility (Bousquet & Bronkhorst, 2021. The major categories of environmental stressors that have been liked to conflict are:

1) scarcity: insufficient natural resources may lead to violent disputes over their access (Ide, 2015).

2) environmental degradation: meaning deterioration of the environment through the depletion, pollution, or destruction of natural resources such as air, water, soil, forest, or wildlife (Blondel, 2012).

3) resource curse: the paradox that countries with an abundance of natural resources tend to have less economic growth, less democracy and worse development outcome that countries with fewer natural resources (Ross, 2013).

4) climate stress: a potentially harmful departure from normal climatic conditions which can take the form of extreme weather events that can trigger a variety of indirect effects on conflicts.

How will climate change have an impact on societies?

As a general finding, the impact of climate change will be such as to make certain lifestyles impracticable and certain areas of the planet uninhabitable. Overall, people living in poverty, in underdeveloped states or under bad governance are going to be the most affected (Smith & Vivekananda, 2007). Recent studies estimate that these socio-economic conditions will make people face the “double-headed problem” of climate change and violent conflict thus diminishing their capability to adapt while increasing the risks of being involved in violent struggles (Smith & Vivekananda, 2007). To evaluate conflict sensitivity to climate change, the International Alert identified the following elements of risk (Smith & Vivekananda, 2007):

1) political instability meaning weak institutional coping ability with the climate emergency.

2) economic weakness in the management of a prompt economic response capacity or in the lack of economic means to meet the challenge.

3) food insecurity: intended both in terms of food shortages and uncertainty of food supply. Climate change, for instance, may destabilize the food supply chain by causing desertification of arable land and altering the seasonal cycle. Variations in temperature and precipitation patterns are crucial for agricultural and livestock in developing countries. Under these circumstances, conflicts and migration may be unavoidable consequences.

4) water scarcity: If climate stress results in a society entering a condition of high-water insecurity, then the control and distribution of water assets can become a dangerous point of contention. Because large rivers are often shared between states, conflicting claims on water resources have often provoke conflicts. These clashes are more likely to be problematic when a strong military state or region is downstream of a weaker military state or region. China, India, Mexico, the Middle East, Southern Africa, and Central Asia are often involved in conflicts over water rights and supply.

5) large-scale migration: as climate change gets worse, it is possible that millions of people could be displaced from their home in search of better living conditions. In most cases displacement ignites the “domino effect of the disaster on the disaster.” Climate-induced migration may increase competition for scarcity over natural resources, like water and livelihoods; create tensions between migrants and established communities and trigger the likelihood of potential struggles between groups for survival (International Alert, 2015).

The Climate-Conflict Nexus:

Although ascertained that geography has a profound influence on military strategy and international politics, the role of climate has scarcely been considered to have such an impact on conflicts. This is a very innovative approach which reflects the extraordinary times we are living in.

The link between climate and conflict is multidimensional, and context related (Mosello et al., 2020). For example, conflicts over natural resources are more likely to burst if there are pre-existing tensions between states and if they have a weak governance which prevents the parties from resolving the problem diplomatically (Bowles, Butler & Morisetti, 2015). What is worth highlighting, is that the relationship between climate and conflicts is mostly indirect. That is, climate change impact will be such as to have several socio-political consequences which will increase the risk of conflict. For instance, drought alone cannot cause armed rebellion because its consequences could be more linked to geopolitical and cultural realms (Theisen, Holtermann, & Buhaug, 2011). To summarize, there are four pathways through which climate impact can indirectly exacerbate conflicts:

1) rising pressure on livelihoods and resources: in countries with weak leadership and marginalized groups, it is much more possible that conflicts over natural resources such as land, water or wood can flare up (Mosello et al., 2020);

2) reduced effectiveness of migration as an adaptation strategy;

3) increased opportunity for non-state armed groups to take the power due to government’s inability to adopt efficient mitigation and adaptation strategies.

4) growing risks in urban environment and violent unrests. Leaders may exploit scarcity to distract the country from structural problems.

The Environmental Security Literature:

Therefore, is climate an environmental stressor for conflict? According to Thomas Homer-Dixon and its school of thought, developing countries are more susceptible to the risk of conflict because they do not have the knowledge and skills to overcome the pressure arising from the lack of endemic resources and reduced economic productivity (Theisen, Holtermann, & Buhaug, 2011). On the other side, quantitative cross-national empirical research has not found robust evidence over the relation between resource scarcity and conflicts, although individual cases present convincing elements in favor (Theisen, Holtermann, & Buhaug, 2011). The economic literature supports an alternative argument to explain such connection. This is based on the negative impact that climate is expected to have on agricultural societies. This will generate an economic loss for the state which will enhance the risk of conflict in two ways. First, it will undermine the government’s prompt ability to respond and provide public goods, thereby increasing incentives for the dissident opposition to take up arms. Second, it will lower the opportunity-cost of individuals to become rebel soldiers. The limit of this state-centric approach lies in the vague description of the actors and the reasons that would prompt them to challenge the government in response to an economic shock caused by climate (Theisen, Holtermann, & Buhaug, 2011). Other scholars have claimed that “there is no direct, short-term relationship between drought and civil war onset, even within contexts presumed most conducive to violence”. Theisen, Holtermann and Buhaug stated that within the same society, individuals could be unequally vulnerable to environmental shocks. While studying Africa they considered the role of ethnopolitical structure, noting that environmental hardships exacerbate social inequality. This is both because marginalized people do not have resources to find an alternative solution, and because they are hardly supported by local governments. Accordingly, “ethnopolitical exclusion is strongly and robustly related to the local risk of civil war” (Theisen, Holtermann, & Buhaug, 2011). Therefore, the authors suggest that the leading cause of intrastate armed conflicts and civil war are not environmental: they are political! This implies that in the future the security of Africa will depend more on its political and socio-economic development rather than on climate actions.

A Threat to International Peace and an Opportunity for Sustainable Development:

There are at least two key reasons that should drive international efforts to address the global climate challenge: maintain international peace and security and support sustainable development. On April 2007, the UN Security Council defined climate change as a threat to international peace and security for all the political, economic, and social implications already described. This statement meant that the phenomenon would be treated as a matter of international security. Since the cost of a civil war is far greater than the costs of adaptation, any reluctance by international community would be counterproductive. On the other hand, the climate crisis could also hinder Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), which are a useful framework for evaluating policies, programs, and projects. Achieving these targets will require unprecedent, fast and well-planned actions to change our economies and societies (Fuso Nerini et. al., 2019). The non-consideration of climate change in development policies and strategies risks jeopardizing the achievement of these aims by 2030.

Conclusion:

“Environmental security is no longer soft politics, it is a “threat multiplier” for instability and conflict that will have repercussions for all.” (Theisen, Holtermann, & Buhaug, 2011). As far as we are aware, if the consequences of climate change will continue to have negative indirect effects on the world’s most serious problems, such as poverty, starvation, inequality, migration, and conflicts, this will put further pressure on already fragile social and political systems, possibly leading them to collapse. International cooperation and coordination are now needed more than ever. Mitigation is essential but in the context of the analysis conducted so far, adaptation needs urgent attention. Relevant actions are encouraged to be undertaken also at regional, national, and private level. Considering the role of climate change today, will create a helpful situation in most countries exposed to the dramatic effects of this global challenge.

REFERENCES:

Blondel, A. (2012), “Climate Change Fuelling Resource-Based Conflicts in the Asia-Pacific”, in Asia-Pacific Human Development Report Background Papers Series 2012/12.

<https://www.uncclearn.org/wp-content/uploads/library/undp304.pdf>. (Accessed on 13 April 2022)

Bousquet, F., Van Bronkhorst, B. (2021), “Tackling the intersecting challenges of climate change, fragility and conflict, World Bank Blogs.

<https://blogs.worldbank.org/dev4peace/tackling-intersecting-challenges-climate-change-fragility-and-conflict.> (Accessed on 8 April 2022)

Bowles, D., Butler, C. and Morisetti, N. (2015), “Climate change, conflict and health”, Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 108(10), pp.390-395.

Ide, T., (2015), “Why do conflicts over scarce renewable resources turn violent? A qualitative comparative analysis”, Global Environmental Change, N.33, pp.61-70.

International Alert (2015), “A new climate for peace: Taking action on climate and fragility risks”.

https://www.international-aler... [Accessed 13 April 2022].

Fuso Nerini, F., Sovacool, B., Hughes, N., Cozzi, L., Cosgrave, E., Howells, M., Tavoni, M., Tomei, J., Zerriffi, H. and Milligan, B. (2019), “Connecting climate action with other sustainable development goals” Nat Sustain 2, 674–680.

https://doi.org/10.1038/s41893-019-0334-y

Mosello B. [et al.] (2020), “Spreading Disease, Spreading Conflict?”, Berlin, Adelphi research gGmbH.

Ross, M., (2013),” The Politics of the Resource Curse: A Review” SSRN Electronic Journal.

Smith, D. and Vivekananda, J., (2007), “A Climate of Conflict: The links between climate change, peace and war”, International Alert.

<https://www.international-alert.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/Climate-Change-Climate-Conflict-EN-2007.pdf> [Accessed 9 April 2022].

Theisen, O. M., Holtermann, H., & Buhaug, H. (2011), “Climate Wars? Assessing the Claim That Drought Breeds Conflict”, International Security, 36(3), 79–106.

By Alessandra Colasanti

Condividi il post