Abstract
The EU Nature Restoration Law is the first comprehensive law of its kind in the European Union, covering the entire continent. This regulation sets mandatory goals for Member States to restore deteriorated ecosystems in the EU, which counts more than 80% of European habitats in poor conditions.
Although many parties and NGOs such as the WWF EU have pleaded for the approval of the law in June 2024, other parties involved have been complaining about the law being approved.
This article will discuss the controversial vote casted by the Austrian Environment Minister Leonore Gewessler, who supported the EU Nature Restoration Law despite her government’s opposition.. As the Austrian vote was the decisive one to reach the qualified majority in the Council, the current turmoil within the Austrian government is endangering the application of the EU Nature Restoration Law.
The article will also argue whether a formal annulment request from the Austrian Government could be submitted to the Court of Justice of the European Union and if such request could be legitimised by the Court, thus invalidating the vote.
Author
Gabriel Silini - Senior Researcher, Mondo Internazionale G.E.O. - Politics
Towards a binding Nature Restoration Law
On May 20, 2020, the European Union published the EU biodiversity strategy for 2023, aiming to build resilience to climate change. In order to reach this goal, the EU set out commitments to be achieved by 2030 in four main thematic areas: building a network of protected areas, creating a binding EU nature restoration plan, supporting transformative change and contributing to a global biodiversity agenda (European Commission, 2024).
Although the EU Biodiversity Strategy for 2030 provided clear targets to protect nature in the EU, it also highlighted that more decisive action is needed if the EU intends to achieve the green objectives for 2030 and 2050 (European Commission, 2024).
In particular, both the European Parliament and the Council have previously insisted on the urgency to adopt binding clauses to restore nature in the EU. The European Parliament Resolution in January 2020 stressed the need to ´propose an ambitious and inclusive Strategy that sets legally binding targets for the EU and its Member States´ (European Parliament, 2024). For this reason, the recognised need for more binding regulations resulted in the drafting of a Nature Restoration Law whose proposal was adopted by the Commission in June 22, 2022.
The main goal of the proposed regulation on nature restoration is to meet the EU's international obligations, help achieve its climate mitigation and adaptation goals, and support the ongoing, long-term, and sustained recovery of biodiverse and resilient nature throughout the EU's land and sea areas through ecosystem restoration. The proposal establishes numerous legally-binding restoration requirements and targets for a wide range of ecosystems in order to accomplish this goal (European Commission, 2022).
These measures are expected to cover at least 20% of the EU´s land and sea regions by 2030, while all ecosystems requiring restoration should be covered by 2050. The proposal has also been supported by an implementation framework which sets out the targets and obligations in national restoration plans.
The goal of the plan is to provide the EU the ability to move quickly and begin rebuilding ecosystems on the basis of legally binding goals and duties that are already measurable and trackable, allowing Member States to work on restoration without further delays (Etifor, 2024).
The Adoption of the Nature Restoration Law and the Austrian case
After more than one year of negotiations, on November 9, 2023, the European Commission, the Parliament and the Council on the Nature Restoration Law reached an agreement. The provisional agreement reached at this stage sets the targets for the final text, which are long-term restoration of nature and implementation of binding restoration measures by the Member States (Dukarm, 2024)
As such, national action will be required, with different restoration targets applicable to different ecosystems with specific measures for each territory. The Member States will thus implement national restoration plans to mitigate climate change (European Commission, 2023)
After the negotiations were concluded, on February 27, 2024, the final text of the law was approved with the planned targets, marking a victory for conservation efforts. According to the law, every Member State now has two years to produce a Restoration Plan to address the conservation needs of the territories and the necessary measures to do so (European Commission, 2024).
Many countries decided to not support the law, among them Hungary, Italy, the Netherlands, Sweden, Belgium, Finland, Poland and Austria. On June 17, 2024, the environment ministers of the Member States met in Luxembourg to vote in favour or against the law. On this day, the Austrian environment minister Leonore Gewessler of the Greens voted in favour of the law on June 17, 2024, although the Austrian government decided to vote against it, thus being the decisive vote to meet the qualified majority according to Article 16(4) of the Treaty on European Union (TEU) (Reuters, 2024)
The Austrian Chancellor Karl Nehammer from the Austrian People's Party ÖVP, who opposed the Nature Restoration Law together with 7 of the 9 Bundesländer - the Regional Governments - claimed that the environment minister Gewessler violated Austrian constitutional law. Nehammer thus announced his intention to present a formal abuse of office complaint to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) asking to nullify the vote of June 2024 (Fohringer, 2024).
As stressed by the Austrian Chancellor, minister Gewessler allegedly acted without considering the decision of the federal and the regional governments. Austria is in fact a federal country composed of 9 Bundesländer, which have legislative power on their own on specific matters according to the Austrian Federal Constitutional Law. Particularly important in this case is that under Art. 23d of the Austrian Constitution Bundes-Verfassungsgesetz (B-VG), the regional governments have rights to participate in projects concerning the EU. Moreover, if a EU decision might affect their legislative competence, the 9 Bundesländer have voting rights and their position is binding for the federal government (Parliament of Austria, 2024).
The Austrian request to nullify the vote for the Nature Restoration Law
As previously mentioned, the Austrian Chancellor intends to request the annulment of the vote from Austria in favour of the Natural Restoration Law, accusing the environment minister of abusing her powers (Der Standard, 2024).
However, according to Article 16(2) TEU, State representatives on ministerial level who are able to commit their governments are allowed to vote. Moreover, Article 73(2) of the B-VG stipulates that Austria is represented in the Council by the responsible Minister, which in this case is indeed Lenore Gewessler for environmental matters. (Dukarm, 2024)
It is also unclear whether one minister can indeed present a request to nullify a vote casted by another minister representing the same Member State. According to Article 263 (2) TFEU, the CJEU has the power to review the legality of legislative ats, thus having jurisdiction on cases brought by Member States as expressed here:
It shall for this purpose have jurisdiction in actions brought by a Member State, the European Parliament, the Council or the Commission on grounds of lack of competence, infringement of an essential procedural requirement, infringement of the Treaties or of any rule of law relating to their application, or misuse of powers (European Union, 2012).
According to case law, the term ´Member State´ refers to the ´authorities of the Member State´. In addition, the case law does not provide a hierarchical order of the ´authorities of the Member State´, allowing the Member State to define its own hierarchy. As such, the Austrian constitution has to be taken into account to identify the internal hierarchical process (Dukarm, 2024). Article 69 (1) of the B-VG states that the Federal Government consists of the Federal Chancellor, the Vice-Chancellor and the Federal Ministers, considering these figures as the highest organs, without defining a clear hierarchy between them and unanimity needs to be reached to pass a resolution (Government of Austria, 2022).
Nonetheless, it is highly unlikely that Environment Minister Gewessler and the remaining 5 ministers from the Green party will vote in favour of submitting an action of annulment to the CJEU.
Moreover, Article 263 TFEU further specifies that:
Acts setting up bodies, offices and agencies of the Union may lay down specific conditions and arrangements concerning actions brought by natural or legal persons against acts of these bodies, offices or agencies intended to produce legal effects in relation to them.
The proceedings provided for in this Article shall be instituted within two months of the publication of the measure, or of its notification to the plaintiff, or, in the absence thereof, of the day on which it came to the knowledge of the latter, as the case may be (European Union, 2012)
As stated in Article 263 TFEU, an action of annulment from Member States can be submitted within two months after the publication of the Nature Restoration Law.
It is worth mentioning that Austria will undergo parliamentary elections on September 29, 2024 and the ÖVP could push for a conservative coalition forcing the Greens to leave the government and return to the opposition. In this way, unanimity to present a formal action of annulment could be reached. Nonetheless, the Nature Restoration Law has been adopted on June 17, 2024 and will be soon published in the Official Journal of the European Union, which will formally start the two months deadline to present any actions of annulment (Dukarm, 2024)
As the Austrian parliamentary elections will be on September 29, 2024, it is hard to imagine that the government will be formed before the deadline to submit a request to nullify the vote of Austria in favour of the Nature Restoration Law.
Conclusions
Although it is still unclear how and if Austria will indeed present a request for the annulment of its vote for the Nature Restoration Law by the deadline, the case would represent the first time the CJEU is requested to judge such cases. However, it is clear that if the CJEU will admit the case, other Member States could in the future decide to nullify a decision taken by their ministers to stop the implementation of a decision voted in the European Council.
It is also worth mentioning that future possible cases which might fulfil the same conditions, as Austria after the elections might be able to reach unanimity within the new government and submit an annulment request within the 2-month-period provided by Article 263 TFEU mentioned above, might be extremely rare. The rarity of the case per se does not imply that, if the CJEU would indeed legitimise the annulment complaint, this could mark a new path for other Member States to overcome controversial votes from their own ministers if they present complaints regarding any new EU disposition.
Nonetheless, assuming the CJEU legitimises Austria´s annulment complaint, the admissibility of such a case might have important repercussions on the relations between member states and Brussels. This could eventually lead to create a first legal procedure for governments of the member states, especially those formed with large coalitions, to block a decision taken at the EU level.
Classification of sources and information:
1 | Confirmed | Confirmed by other independent sources; logical in itself; coherent with other information on the topic |
2 | Presumably true | Not confirmed; logical in itself; coherent with other information on the topic |
3 | Maybe true | Not confirmed; reasonably logical in itself; coherent with some other information on the topic |
4 | Uncertain | Not confirmed; possible but not logical in itself; no other information on the topic |
5 | Improbable | Not confirmed; not logical in itself; contradicts with other information on the topic |
6 | Not able to be evaluated | No basis to evaluate the validity of the information |
Trustworthiness of the source | ||
A | Trustworthy | No doubt about authenticity, reliability or competence; has a history of total trustworthiness |
B | Normally trustworthy | Small doubts about authenticity, reliability or competence, nevertheless has a history of valid information in a majority of cases |
C | Sufficiently trustworthy | Doubts about authenticity, reliability or competence; however, has supplied valid information in the past |
D | Normally not trustworthy | Significant doubt about authenticity, reliability or competence, however has supplied valid information in the past |
E | Not trustworthy | Lack of authenticity, reliability or competence; history of invalid information |
F | Not able to be evaluated | No basis to evaluate the validity of the information |
References
Dukarm, S (2024) "Vienna Calling Luxembourg: About the Admissibility of an Action for Annulment of the Nature Restoration Law." European Law Blog, July 15, 2024. https://europeanlawblog.eu/2024/07/15/vienna-calling-luxembourg-about-the-admissibility-of-an-action-for-annulment-of-the-nature-restoration-law/ 2A
European Commission (2023) "Commission Welcomes Political Agreement on Nature Restoration Law." European Commission Press Corner. Accessed August 12, 2024. https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_23_5662 1A
European Commission (2024) "Nature Restoration Law." Accessed August 12, 2024. https://environment.ec.europa.eu/topics/nature-and-biodiversity/nature-restoration-law_en 1A
European Commission (2022) "Proposal for a Regulation of the European Parliament and of the Council on Nature Restoration." Accessed August 13, 2024. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/DOC/?uri=CELEX:52022PC0304 1A
European Parliament (2024) "New EU Biodiversity Strategy." Legislative Train Schedule. Accessed August 13, 2024. https://www.europarl.europa.eu/legislative-train/theme-a-european-green-deal/file-new-eu-biodiversity-strategy#:~:text=On%2016%20January%202020%2C%20Parliament%20adopted%20a%20resolution,natural%20areas%20and%20restore%20degraded%20ecosystems%20by%202030
European Union (2012) "Treaty on European Union." EUR-Lex. Accessed August 19, 2024. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=celex%3A12012E%2FTXT 1A
Etifor (2024) "The European Parliament Adopts the Nature Restoration Law." Accessed August 21, 2024. https://www.etifor.com/en/updates/nature-restoration-law/#:~:text=The%20European%20Parliament%20adopts%20the%20Nature%20Restoration%20Law,by%202030%20and%20all%20endangered%20habitats%20by%202050 2A
Fohringer, H (2024) "Renaturierung: 214VP Verfasste Amtsmissbrauchs-Anzeige Gegen Gewessler." Der Standard. Accessed August 21, 2024. https://www.derstandard.at/story/3000000225121/renaturierung-214vp-verfasste-amtsmissbrauchs-anzeige-gegen-gewessler 2B
Government of Austria (2022) “Bundes-Verfassungsgesetz”. Accessed August 18, 2024. https://www.ris.bka.gv.at/GeltendeFassung.wxe?Abfrage=Bundesnormen&Gesetzesnummer=10000138&FassungVom=2022-03-21 1A
Parliament of Austria (2024) “The Federal State of Austria”. Accessed September 06, 2024. https://www.parlament.gv.at/en/explore/political-system/the-federal-state-of-austria/index.html#:~:text=The%20Republic%20of%20Austria%20is%20a%20Federal%20State,Constitution%20and%20can%20only%20be%20changed%20by%20referendum. 1A
Reuters (2024) "Austrian Minister Defies Coalition Ally to Back EU Nature Restoration Law." June 16, 2024. https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/austrian-minister-defies-coalition-ally-back-eu-nature-restoration-law-2024-06-16/ 2B
Riproduzione Riservata ®