Shaleesha Perera, Junior Researcher
Mondo Internazionale Sri Lanka
1. The relationship between United States and Israel
The United States, as a superpower, has a tremendous worldwide influence. Stability in the Middle East is relatively valuable to America, concern for a variety of motives, including the worldwide oil market, and the United States assumed the position of guarantee of the region's security. The US and Israel have developed a connection in an attempt to control the Middle East's oil resources. In addition to meeting its energy needs, the US wants to grow its economy, keep its position as the dominant power in the Middle East, and prove its superiority to those who oppose it, desire to restructure Arab territories based on political interests and importantly that they could avoid an economic collapse in the near future.
Middle East powers such as Egypt, Saudi Arabia, and Israel were positive to the USA and its generally conservative strategy for Middle Eastern regional politics unlike Iran, Syria, and Saddam's Iraq. However, certain conflicts occurred when it was not in the United States' geopolitical interests, such as when Bush refused to agree to back an Israeli war on Iran, and Obama constantly argued with Israeli officials over West Bank settlements. However, Israel is strategically relevant in many cases as a moderating force in the Middle East, averting unrest that may compromise America's access to the region's oil supply. The political, moral, and material advantages of US relations with Israel are not outweighed by them. It's merely the cost of maintaining the special relationship, which has emotional as well as military and political overtones.
Particularly in the Middle East, the United States finds it hard to accept its perspective of Islamic radicals. Extremist groups in the Middle East, such as al-Qaeda and ISIS, are long-term barriers to American progress and success. In an attempt to achieve its objectives, the United States of America has set up military personnel in many Middle Eastern nations. The action was taken to keep an eye on the flow of oil and deal with the instability that the region was experiencing due to the danger of extremism. The United States' restricted connections with Israel have been grounded in two basic views. The initial viewpoint is that Israel serves as a "strategic asset" in a turbulent region of the world. The second point is that Israel is a "heroic democracy, the only democracy in the Middle East, thus, it shares the same values as the United States". Critics, however, have questioned both of those narratives.
Israel's security is also maintained by the USA. Israel's strong support for the US stems from the fact that the US has provided crucial economic help to Israel. Since 1985, the US has extended financial offers to Israel totalling about $3 billion annually. Even while the US still gives Israel a lot of financial help, the bulk of US bilateral aid now takes the shape of Foreign Military Financing (FMF). Israel's security forces are now among the most modernised in the world thanks in part to U.S. military assistance. The United States Defense Ministry receives around half of all FMF and 20% of Israel's defence budget. Congress routinely provides additional funding of millions of dollars annually to Israel for the Iron Dome anti-rocket system for joint missile defence programs between the US and Israel, such as Arrow and David's Sling. The goal of this assistance to Israel is to keep Israel's military superior to those of its neighbours.
Israel and the US signed several agreements and pacts. The cooperative defence pact, which was inked as part of the US's tripartite treaty security arrangements with Israel and the United Arab Emirates, is one important accord. Similar to NATO clause 5, it declares that in the event of a military threat, the United States will defend the monarchy. NATO's Article 5 stipulates that "each member of the alliance will regard this act of violence as an armed assault on all members and will take any action deemed necessary to assist the allied attack if a NATO ally is the victim of an armed attack." (Arab Center for Research and Policy Studies, 2023)
An important proposal of the USA is the two state solution which is a reform bought by the USA as a peace agreement between Gaza and Israel. An important obstacle to a two-state solution is the militant group's denial of the legitimacy of Israel to remain in existence. The Biden administration's broader Middle East policy entails Israel consenting to the creation of a Palestinian state by embracing the two-state solution. The idea is that Israelis and Palestinians both would have their country separately, that Israel is a Jewish state, and Palestinians a Palestinian one. Simply accepting a demilitarised Palestinian state with limited sovereignty over part of the Palestinian territories. Also, Israel’s recognition of the Palestinian state would prompt Saudi Arabia to normalise relations with Israel. As a result of this normalisation, the US would reward Saudi Arabia by meeting several long standing demands from Saudi Arabia. The most important of these is to sign a strategic partnership agreement approved by the US Congress, which would provide Saudi Arabia with full security guarantees. In addition, there would be many other privileges or meeting important demands for Saudi national security. Therefore, Israeli recognition of Palestine and Saudi recognition of Israel would pave the way for other Islamic countries to recognise Israel. It would make it easier for the US to lead the creation of a new alliance made up of Israel, the Arab and Islamic nations that have normalised relations with Israel. After that, this friend would take on Iran and lessen China's and Russia's sway over the Middle East.
2. Can or cannot US Involvement pause the Gaza War
The USA has always avoided answering the question of stopping the war. With the recent Israel Hamas war the U.S. authorities have refrained from explicitly expressing that any specific Israeli actions in Gaza were inappropriate. When journalists questioned US officials directly on Israel's actions in Gaza, they equivocated. "We're not going to adjudicate each and every tactical event," said John Kirby, a White House spokeswoman," The U.S. military [is] not participating in IDF target development [or] helping them run their campaign it is their operation, they’re running their operation.” said Patrick Ryder, the Pentagon press secretary.
Not on the list is ending the Israel-Hamas conflict. This is mainly because the United States supports Israel's objective of eliminating Hamas. “We still don’t believe that a general cease-fire is appropriate at this time,” National Security Council spokesperson John Kirby told reporters Monday. “When we talk about a general cease-fire, what that means is a complete cessation of fighting across all of Gaza, which we believe at this point in time benefits Hamas.” Hamas is a proxy of Iran, a major U.S. adversary.
Section 502B of the Foreign aid Act requires the State Department to ensure that US security aid does not facilitate severe breaches of human rights. The Biden administration also the Civilian hurt Investigations and Response Guidance, which require the State Department to examine accusations that US weapons were used to hurt people. So the USA perfectly knows what they are breaching the law by helping the Israeli forces. But USA is in a firm position to help the Isrealities even by going against the law. For the third time at the Security Council, the United States rejected Algeria's draft resolution calling for an end to Israel's genocide against the Palestinian people in the Gaza Strip. This action demonstrated America's obvious hostility against Israel once more. This partiality mostly results from the strategic confluence of the interests of the two nations.
With all these situations the United States' credibility has been harmed by unpredictability and hypocritical conduct. In 2016, President Barack Obama attacked Syrian President Bashar al-Assad's refusal to provide food and water to residents in Aleppo as how they are doing the exact same thing to Gaza's civilian population. Biden administration has encouraged Netanyahu to let more aid into Gaza, but has not explicitly attacked the siege.“ Israeli forces have used white phosphorus, a chemical that ignites when in contact with oxygen, causing horrific and severe burns, on densely populated neighbourhoods,” Human Rights Watch senior legal adviser Clive Baldwin wrote in late October. “White phosphorus can burn down to the bone, and burns to 10 percent of the human body are often fatal.” Baldwin added: “Israel has also engaged in the collective punishment of Gaza’s population through cutting off food, water, electricity, and fuel. This is a war crime, as is willfully blocking humanitarian relief from reaching civilians in need.”
The US now provides the Israeli military with a vast quantity of money, military information, ammunition, weapons of all types, and equipment. It has also become its major source of support. Additionally, it appears that the US has made some steps to help the Palestinian people by lessening their suffering and anguish.
So can the USA stop the Hamas Israel war could be answered by determining various factors. Biden's propensity to please the US Zionist lobby, particularly in the run-up to elections. Above all, the United States has a deep affinity to Israel, particularly with a president who takes great delight in being a Zionist. Over six years spanning more than three decades, Biden was consistently one of the Senate's most steadfast advocates of Israel. He openly expressed one's unwavering love and support for Israel. Even before Biden being president he had shown much delight to please Israel. Some instances are In 1975, Biden submitted a joint letter to grant Israel with the military assistance it requested and Biden was the sole senator who backed Israel's actions during the siege of Lebanon. In 1984, he took the initiative in convincing Congress that Israel was bound to receive adequate economic aid from the US to pay the expenses of its military acquisitions.
The impact of lobbying is also a major concern. AIPAC is America's largest pro-Israel lobby. AIPAC is an extremely influential lobbying group. Its power is linked to different sources. The nature of the US political system enables special interest groups to exert enormous power. They can lobby, offer political contributions, and spend as much money as they like on commercials and other forms of communication. In 1953, in response to the murder of three Jewish inhabitants, Israeli troops killed 69 civilians in the West Bank hamlet of Qibya. The incident sparked a fierce international response. The organisation went into damage control, working to repair Israel's reputation in the aftermath of the deaths. Since then, AIPAC's interests have expanded beyond fundraising. But on the other hand AIPAC and its supporters pressure the US to behave against its own interests
"The unmatched power of the Israel Lobby," Walt and Mearsheimer write, is "the" explanation for America's continued strong support for Israel. Some criticisms is that They don't provide much direct proof that AIPAC lobbying affected specific votes and that Israel is not needed to to backed up but the only reason to back up is the existence of AIPAC. Biden received more money than almost any other senator in history — $4.2 million — from pro-Israel organizations. Biden's candidacy was supported by AIPAC lobbyists "because he has long been vocal in support of Israel." Over the period of around ten years, Biden's shift from being an opponent to a supporter of Israeli settlements may seem to be explained by funding from AIPAC. That personal connection is the main reason behind the president's remarkable endorsement of Israel after October 7. Also Biden cannot escalate the situation alone without the consent of Israel. It is important to determine whether Biden want to make a difference or just make a point.
According to Israel Institute program director Michael Koplow, the single most important element driving the US-Israel relationship appears to be the American public's broad and deep support for Israel. "The average gap between those holding favourable and unfavourable views of Israel over [the past four administrations] is 31 points." That means that the public opinion is biassed towards supporting Israel. Roughly six-in-ten Americans (58%) say Israel’s reasons for fighting Hamas are valid. But how Israel is carrying out its response to Hamas’ Oct. 7 attack receives a more mixed evaluation. About four-in-ten U.S. adults (38%) say Israel’s conduct of the war has been acceptable, and 34% say it has been unacceptable. The remaining 26% are unsure.
One major factor for US Israel support is a sense of "shared values." According to Barnett, the American moral image of Israel — "the only democracy in the Middle East," for example — is the "foundation of US-Israeli relations." Faith-based organisations are two additional key considerations. American Jews and evangelical Christians are among the most politically engaged communities in the United States. They are key constituents in the Democratic and Republican parties. And both are strongly pro-Israel. According to Pew Research Center data, American Jewish attitudes of the US-Israel relationship are generally consistent. 54 percent of American Jews believe the United States provides adequate support for Israel, while 31 percent believe it falls short. In contrast, 31% of white evangelicals believe the US has reached the appropriate level of support, while 46% believe the US should help Israel more.
There is some pressure on the US president to support Israel. Congress is the direct source of pressure. Additionally, there has been a good deal of support for Israel in Congress generally, both from Democrats and Republicans, where approval is particularly strong. Israel has direct power, and the president may be under pressure to back down from any threats from Congress given its strong backing. Times reported that the Biden administration is seeking congressional permission “to unilaterally blanket-approve the future sale of military equipment and weapons — like ballistic missiles and artillery ammunition — to Israel without notifying Congress.” And so, “the Israeli government would be able to purchase up to $3.5 billion in military articles and services in complete secrecy.”
3. Measures The USA could implement to stop the war
Since Netanyahu's goal is to destroy Hamas, Biden cannot persuade Netanyahu to change his views, but he needs Israel to make a hostage agreement since it is the only way to buy a brief cease-fire and defuse the situation. Israel needs to facilitate the delivery of humanitarian supplies to Gaza.
With regard to slow walking, limiting military assistance, supporting or abstaining from UN Security Council resolutions that criticise Israel, and requesting an end to hostilities that are autonomous of any agreements involving the release of hostages are some steps the USA can follow. In return for the immediate release of hundreds of Palestinian prisoners, Biden said that the first phase of the proposed agreement would involve a "full and complete ceasefire," the expulsion of Israeli forces from all inhabited parts of Gaza, and the release of several hostages, including women, the elderly, and the wounded. This first phase of the agreement would last for six weeks. Israeli forces would leave Gaza during the following phase, which would also see the liberation of all surviving hostages, particularly male soldiers. Furthermore, Gaza must begin a massive reconstruction effort in the third phase in order to recover from the war's damage, which will take decades to complete." This new phase needs to be started. for the release of the captives. for Israel's security and the end of the suffering. This conflict needs to end now. For the following day to start," Biden stated. So as Biden stated, he should take the necessary steps to implement these actions so that it will not be only words but also words placed into action and overall the War could be halted.
So when answering whether Biden has the authority to implement a cease fire. Yes, Biden can stop the war, we could turn our focus to the past. Like other commanders-in-chief before him, Biden has a great deal of influence and is by no means helpless in his role as the head of the richest nation in history. According to Bruce Riedel, a longtime CIA advisor, "The US has immense leverage." Additionally, he stated, "We give Israel the missiles, drones, and ammunition it needs to sustain a major military campaign like the campaign in Gaza every day." However, "American presidents have been notably shy about using that leverage for domestic political reasons," according to Riedel's admission. So if the USA stops the providing of ammunition, drones etc.. the power of Israel would be stopped to some extent.
Biden has significant power because he is a member of Israel's defence establishment. Israeli MPs questioned Defense Minister Yoav Gallant's decision to let very limited humanitarian supplies into Gaza prior to the release of any captives. How did Gallant respond? "The Americans persisted, and we are not in a position to reject them. We rely on them for aircraft and military equipment. What should we do? "Tell them no?" Israelis are unable to "refuse" to accept Americans. The US president could "turn off the tap" and stop the killing in Gaza by removing weapons, ammunition, and intelligence. Since Biden has experience doing this, he can prevent Netanyahu from massacring Palestinians in Gaza. Israel attacked the Gaza Strip for eleven days in a row in May 2021, killing over 100 Palestinians — 66 of them children. Then president Biden intervened and then later a ceasefire came into effect. The president is affectionately called the "comforter-in-chief" by his supporters. His staff refers to him as a "devout Catholic." He has spoken extensively and with emotion on loss, grief, and suffering.
4. Gaza war effect on the next president of USA
In 2024, there will be intense competition for the US presidency. Due to his participation in the 2021 Capitol Hill storming, former President Donald Trump is very unpopular and undercut by the animosity of a resolute group inside his own party. Meanwhile, Joe Biden continues to remain unpopular with Americans. A lot of people think that the current President is too elderly to be in office, and voters in the United States are clearly not satisfied with the way he has handled the nation's economy and its present foreign policy. This has given rise to serious questions about the President's age. Because of this, the swing states' elections will likely be determined by a narrow margin of votes.
Another significant issue is the voting patterns of Arabs and Muslims. The Arab and Muslim bloc is adamant about punishing Joe Biden for his backing of the Israeli military assault in Gaza, but US President Donald Trump has also made two actions: Israel's acquisition of the Golan Heights and the US Embassy's move to Jerusalem. Nonetheless, a portion of these groups' members are hesitant to back Trump and will probably abstain or cast their votes for a different candidate. Biden could easily offset the losses among Arab and Muslim voters by improving its performance among other demographic groups. So, Biden won't face much opposition from the Muslim and Arab votes. Also Michigan is one of the important swing factors and the Arab and Muslim community may tip the scales in the 2024 election.
A significant Muslim American group is anticipated to organise in an effort to influence voters against selecting Biden. They argue that Biden has betrayed the nation by not defending peace and the genuine rights of the Palestinian people in the same way that America defends the rights of the Israeli people. Second, they find it irritating that the US has done nothing to stop the tragedy in Gaza. They find it shocking that the US continues to oppose UN Security Council resolutions demanding an immediate cessation of hostilities in Gaza.
References
- The Impact of America Seeking Oil Profits by Diplomatic Bridging the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and Israel Gaga Desga Griandana; Joko Setiyono https://ijmmu.com/index.php/ijmmu/article/view/5863
- Israel: Background and U.S. Relations Jim Zanotti Specialist in Middle Eastern Affairs. https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/pdfs/ADA608579.pdf
- How the US became Israel's closest ally. https://www.vox.com/world-politics/23916266/us-israel-support-ally-gaza-war-aid
- Why the US has the most pro-Israel foreign policy in the world https://www.vox.com/2014/7/24/5929705/us-israel-friends
- Strategic interest and lobby power.The influence behind Bidens support for Israel. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/longform/2024/1/30/strategic-interests-lobby-power-what-influences-bidens-israel-support
- How to end America's hypocrisy on Gaza. https://www.hrw.org/news/2024/02/08/how-end-americas-hypocrisy-gaza
- US double standards hypocrisy. https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202403/1308912.shtml
- Why does the Biden Administration not want a ceasefire. https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/20240406-why-does-the-biden-administration-not-want-a-ceasefire-in-gaza/
- The lifelong incoherence in Biden's Israel strategy. https://www.thenation.com/article/politics/biden-israel-policy-netanyahu/
- Why the US has the most pro israel foreign policy. https://www.vox.com/2014/7/24/5929705/us-israel-friends
- Why Biden can't force a truce on Israel. https://foreignpolicy.com/2024/03/28/biden-netanyahu-israel-gaza-hamas-ceasefire-war/
- Majority in the U.S. Say Israel Has Valid Reasons for Fighting; Fewer Say the Same About Hamas. https://www.pewresearch.org/2024/03/21/majority-in-u-s-say-israel-has-valid-reasons-for-fighting-fewer-say-the-same-about-hamas/
- Biden unveils Israeli proposal to end Gaza war. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cw8860gn1nwo
- A massacre by any other name: Israel’s military is part of the U.S. war machine https://www.salon.com/2023/11/07/a-massacre-by-any-other-name-israels-military-is-part-of-the-us-machine/
- Biden unveils Israeli three-step plan to end war in Gaza https://www.euronews.com/2024/06/01/biden-says-hamas-no-longer-capable-of-carrying-out-large-scale-attack-on-israel
- Biden can end the bombing of Gaza right now. Here’s how (This article is more than 4 months old Mehdi Hasan) https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/feb/21/biden-stop-gaza-bombing-genocide-israel
- The “Muslim factor”, the impact of the Israel-Hamas War on the US presidential elections https://www.geopolitica.info/the-impact-of-the-israel-hamas-war-on-the-us-presidential-elections/
- Why the U.S. isn’t stopping this war, and other Middle East realities https://www.politico.com/news/2023/11/07/why-the-u-s-doesnt-want-to-stop-this-war-and-other-middle-east-realities-00125860
- Why the U.S. isn’t stopping this war, and other Middle East realities https://www.vox.com/2018/11/20/18080094/israel-palestine-two-state-solution-vs-one-state-olution
- Why does the United States refuse to stop the war in Gaza? https://moderndiplomacy.eu/2024/02/26/why-does-the-united-states-refuse-to-stop-the-war-in-gaza/