Elections in Turkey - The crisis and the earthquake make Erdogan tremble

  Focus - Allegati
  16 March 2023
  9 minutes, 40 seconds

Abstract

The upcoming elections in Turkey will represent a defining moment for President Erdogan's regime. The recent earthquake that shook the southern regions has aggravated the already precarious conditions of the country. Ankara is caught in the grip of inflation and the economic crisis, unable to manage the refugees from Syria and covered by protests against what appears to be an increasingly despotic and inefficient government. President Erdogan’s uncertain fate, which has now risen to be an actor of primary importance on the global scene, could prove to be decisive for the future of many.

Author

Michele Gioculano - Senior Researcher, Mondo Internazionale G.E.O. - Politics

Introduction

One hundred years after the proclamation of the Republic, Turkey is preparing to vote in a more uncertain scenario than ever, between economic crisis and seismic emergency. Instead of the 18th of June, the natural deadline of the legislature, the renewal of the Parliament and the election of the President have been set for the 14th of May. This advance was expressly desired by President Erdogan, wishing to recall, symbolically, the election day of 1950, when, for the first time, the conservatives, led by Celâl Bayar, defeated the progressives of İsmet İnönü. However, some argue that the date change could hide the desire to prevent a further decline in the support of the AKP, the Justice and Development Party founded and led by Erdogan. Suffering from a slow but apparently inexorable decline, accentuated especially during the last term, the President is aware of the fundamental importance of this electoral session for his political future.

New and old concerns to face

The earthquake that hit southern Anatolia on February 6th, especially the regions along the Syrian border, has completely upset Turkey and its political and social balance. With a magnitude of 7.8 on the Richter scale, the earthquake caused tens of thousands of deaths, hundreds of thousands of injured and more than five million displaced. This transformed a violent natural event into a real humanitarian tragedy to which the Government was unable to respond effectively, especially in the early days. Relief efforts proved to be slow and inadequate and the affected populations remained exposed to the cold temperatures and bad weather conditions for a long time, as well as being deprived of medical assistance and basic necessities. The lack of means and resources, only partially filled by the support granted to Ankara by neighboring countries, was compounded by the inexperience of the workers mobilized, thus revealing a general organizational deficiency. It should also be mentioned the immense amount of material damage that affected public infrastructures as well as private buildings, evidently lacking the anti-seismic requirements. This has raised a flood of protests and criticisms for the lack of building controls and the corruption surrounding the world of procurement and authorizations in Turkey. Therefore, in addition to presenting a new and arduous challenge to President Erdogan, the recent earthquake has highlighted an undergrowth of inefficiency and malfeasance that characterizes his administration.

Furthermore, it is essential to remember that the earthquake hit some of the poorest provinces of Turkey, which are suffering from marked underdevelopment and high unemployment. This general condition has been further aggravated by the lack of management of the refugees from Syria. In fact, despite the commitment made in 2016 with the European Union for the control of migratory flows and the huge funding received, Ankara has not adopted adequate reception and integration policies. This has resulted in severe socio-economic consequences and growing discontent among the population. Tensions have grown to the point of pushing the Administration to elaborate a policy of resettlement of refugees in northern Syria, currently under Turkish control. In this way, President Erdogan aims to achieve a domestic policy objective, to appease popular discontent, and a foreign policy objective, to strengthen Turkish control over the occupied Syrian regions through a large ethnic engineering operation. On the one hand, clearing out most of the refugee camps, Erdogan would satisfy the demands of his citizens. On the other hand, transferring millions of Sunni Arabs to northern Syria, would weaken the hopes of autonomy of the current Kurdish majority present in those territories. However, the implementation of these measures immediately encountered several difficulties, which were further amplified by the consequences of the earthquake.

These difficulties are part of a framework already full of pitfalls for the Turkish regime. Over the past few years, despite the control on the media and the crackdown on dissent carried out following the failed 2016 coup, President Erdogan has been unable to increase his popularity and silence the opponents. On the contrary, consensus has continued to decline under the weight of the failures and scandals that have affected his administration. The purge of soldiers, magistrates, officials and journalists accentuated the authoritarian nature of the government. Likewise, the clumsy economic policies implemented by the Turkish Treasury have not improved living conditions but, on the contrary, have increased the social gap and favored nepotism and corruption. A considerable change in political orientation, especially on the part of the urban middle classes, occurred during the local elections of 2019. On that occasion, all the major cities of the country, including Istanbul, Ankara, Izmir and Antalya, rewarded the progressive coalition, dealing a severe blow to the image of the regime. Not even the suspected electoral fraud was able to prevent such an unfavourable result. Since then, the President's image has begun to deteriorate, just as the stability of his power has increasingly been questioned. Nonetheless, it should be remembered that the AKP still enjoys considerable support in the interior regions of Anatolia. Mostly inhabited by conservative rural communities, poorly educated and deeply religious, that still constitute a considerable and solid pool of votes for Erdogan's Party, despite suffering the consequences of the prolonged economic crisis gripping the country.

For some time, in fact, the Turkish economy has been in the vortex of a serious inflationary spiral from which it is unable to escape. In contrast to what has been done in the rest of the world, the Erdogan administration has continuously adopted heterodox policies that have contributed to aggravating the situation. For example, the artificial maintenance of low interest rates, aimed at encouraging the granting of credit and private investment, has not produced any significant benefits. On the contrary, it has led to a considerable increase in inflation, which is now around 60%. Similarly, several competitive devaluations, implemented by the Central Bank to favor exports, have led the Turkish lira to lose about 40% of its value against the euro and the dollar in the last year (ISPI). These recipes have upset the trade balance and slowed down development, favouring only the pro-government cartels that are suppressing the country's entrepreneurial vitality. They have also aroused the wrath of the lower and middle classes, victims of a significant erosion of their purchasing power and a drastic drop in their living standards. Even the recent measures adopted to support consumption do not seem to have completely appeased the general discontent.

The inadequacy of post-earthquake relief, such as the inability to contain the protests and the poor management of the economic crisis and of the migratory flows, reveal a lack of pervasiveness by the Turkish regime. Despite the adoption of a more incisive vigilance on the media and the isolation of many opponents, President Erdogan has failed to improve his image or to divert the public’s attention from the real problems of the country. Despite the authoritarian turn taken by his government, the bad moods and the unease among the population have grown over the years while consensus has decreased. The ineffective control over the majority of the public opinion and the inability to properly direct the vote greatly concern Erdogan. Fear for his political future prompted him to bring forward the date of the elections and to grant support to families, which are particularly burdensome for the state budget. Even the adoption of impromptu and ill-considered measures after the earthquake, such as the blocking of some information channels and the immediate arrest of some builders, underlined the President's concern.

Conclusions

In conclusion, it can be argued that, at the moment, the result of the upcoming Turkish elections is far from obvious. President Erdogan, mired in a disastrous economic crisis and suffering from a significant decrease in consensus, sees his leadership threatened by popular discontent that has already undermined the stability of the regime in the past. Added to this, there are the consequences of the earthquake that hit the south of the country, an area characterized by a precarious balance, but particularly important for the Administration's projects. The absence of a capillary control over public opinion and information could lead to a welding between the economic and social problems and the poor management of the earthquake emergency, increasing hostility towards the government in office. This would make a new victory for the AKP much more difficult and would open up completely new scenarios for a country which, as never before, plays a pivotal role for geopolitical balances, both regional and global.

By a strange coincidence, it was precisely an economic crisis, the one that afflicted Turkey in 2001, and an earthquake, the one that hit Istanbul in 1999, that allowed President Erdogan to rise to power. Skilfully riding popular discontent and mismanagement of the emergency, he gathered a broad consensus and was elected Prime Minister in 2003. Similarly, today, the inflationary spiral and migratory chaos, combined with mismanagement of the post-earthquake phase, could determine his exit from the scene. He who lives by the sword, dies by the sword.


Classification of sources and information:

1

Confirmed

Confirmed by other independent sources; logical in itself; coherent with other information on the topic

2

Presumably true

Not confirmed; logical in itself; coherent with other information on the topic

3

Maybe true

Not confirmed; reasonably logical in itself; coherent with some other information on the topic

4

Uncertain

Not confirmed; possible but not logical in itself; no other information on the topic

5

Improbable

Not confirmed; not logical in itself; contradicts with other information on the topic

6

Not able to be evaluated

No basis to evaluate the validity of the information

Trustworthiness of the source

A

Trustworthy

No doubt about authenticity, reliability or competence; has a history of total trustworthiness

B

Normally trustworthy

Small doubts about authenticity, reliability or competence, nevertheless has a history of valid information in a majority of cases

C

Sufficiently trustworthy

Doubts about authenticity, reliability or competence; however, has supplied valid information in the past

D

Normally not trustworthy

Significant doubt about authenticity, reliability or competence, however has supplied valid information in the past

E

Not trustworthy

Lack of authenticity, reliability or competence; history of invalid information

F

Not able to be evaluated

No basis to evaluate the validity of the information

Bibliography:

Share the post