Authors
Sharon Giacomelli - Junior Researcher G.E.O. Politics
Miriam Viscusi - Junior Researcher G.E.O. Environment
Introduction
“We are the first generation to feel the effect of climate change and the last generation who can do something about it.” (Obama, 2014).
These words, tweeted by former US President Barack Obama on X (Twitter at the time) in 2014, resonate as strongly today as they did ten years ago. Climate change represents an essential threat to our economy and society and, ultimately, but more importantly, to our lives.
Scientists have long warned of the urgency of drastically reducing our CO2 emissions and limiting the increase in the average world temperature. World leaders have met several times every year to attempt to find solutions to this existential problem. The outcomes of some of these meetings are important agreements like the Kyoto Protocol signed in 1997 and the Paris Agreement made in 2015. These accords commit nations to very ambitious goals, such as cutting greenhouse emissions and keeping global warming below 1.5°C. However, the actions taken until now have been far from sufficient.
According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), global temperatures are projected to rise by 1.5°C between 2021 and 2040 if current trends continue.
Due to this change, extreme events are more likely and more frequent worldwide. Their impacts on vulnerable groups of people and ecosystems are already significant and will probably be even more critical. Even though humanity has tried and is still trying to find effective and efficient adaptation strategies, researchers believe that some effects of climate change have become so severe that they are deemed irreversible. That means that humans cannot adapt and have to expect huge losses and damages.
While political efforts often fall short, parts of global civil society have stepped up to demand immediate action. Climate change movements were born decades ago, yet in the last years, they are increasing in numbers. They want to amplify their voices, urging politicians to act. That is the reason why climate movements use slogans like “There is no Planet B”, “We can’t eat money”, and “The future in your hands”. Yet, political leaders appear to be more focused on suppressing these demonstrations than addressing the crisis itself. In fact, on many occasions governments prioritise controlling the demonstrations, especially when they involve hundreds of people, rather than addressing the root causes of the unrest. In doing so, they focus on implementing symbolic politics and not on finding sustainable solutions.
An example is France under the Presidency of Emmanuel Macron. France has been one the main architects of the Paris Climate Agreement of 2015, one of the most important symbols of the fight against climate change. It strongly supports the European Green Deal and the ambitious climate policy of the EU wanted by President Von Der Leyen. As many other European States, it has committed to reducing greenhouse gas emissions and achieving carbon neutrality by 2050. To do so, it has adopted several measures, like the ban of short domestic flights. However, analysts point out that these decisions are more symbolic than actually effective. Moreover, the French government tends to reprime demonstrations. For instance, in 2023, 30.000 protesters organised a march to manifest their opposition to the construction of a large water storage project in Sainte-Soline, a region in mid-western France. This demonstration saw the participation of both farmers and environmentalists, like the network called Soulèvements de la Terre (SDT, Rebellions of the Earth in English). Even though the demonstration was banned by local authorities, protesters showed anyway. The response of the policy has been extremely harsh: they used, in fact, military means such as tear gas and explosive grenades to chase the protesters away from the project site. As a result, thousands of people remained injured, a few of them very seriously. This dynamic shows how symbolic climate commitments can coexist with attempts to suppress environmental activism.
This article will focus on some European climate movements and how their governments have been trying and are trying to regulate their actions.
European climate movements
In recent years, climate change and environmentalism have become increasingly important for European civil society. This is shown by the Eurobarometer results (EU, 2023) and the numerous demonstrations that have occurred since then in all European countries.
The most prominent activist group, Friday For Future, was founded by a young Swedish student, Greta Thunberg, in 2018. Greta stopped going to school to condemn government inaction on climate. She sat outside the Swedish parliament with a sign reading “school strike for climate.” Unexpectedly, her actions spread worldwide, and in a year, thousands of students started striking. By the end of 2018, Friday for Future had become a global movement.
Many other smaller groups were born from that year. Two significant examples are Extinction Rebellion (XR) and Last Generation. XR started in 2018 with a Declaration of Rebellion in which it is stated that, due to the deterioration of the climate situation and the inaction of politicians, its members will act in peaceful ways, meaning with civil disobedience, to be heard and to apply informed solutions (Extinction Rebellion, 2018). The document led to 10.000 people protesting on the streets of London the following year. Now, XR is a global movement made up of numerous local groups.
Three years later, Last Generation began its demonstrations in Germany. The demands of its members are similar to those of XR. Last Generation is mainly known due to their blockades of streets and highways. Their protests are often shown on their media channels, with the goal of creating viral attention and involvement. Started in Berlin, it has spread to other European countries, like Italy, France, and the Netherlands.
This first part of the article focuses on the actions of climate movements in Italy, the United Kingdom, Denmark, and Germany, and the actions they use to protest against their governments.
1. Italy
In recent times, Italy has been experiencing several extreme weather events. According to the International Energy Agency, average annual temperatures on the Italian peninsula have risen by 1 degree Celsius in the past century, more strongly than the world average (IEA, 2022). Rising temperatures and shifting precipitation patterns are causing more frequent flooding, such as in the Emilia Romagna region, while others, like Sicily, suffer from severe droughts.
These are just examples of the effects of climate change in Italy, but many others can be listed, with serious consequences on the economy, people’s lifestyles, and safety.
The Italian government has been trying to implement policies to limit the impact of climate change. Its efforts are included in the National Integrated Energy and Climate Plan (PNIEC) which outlines the most important fields. The PNIEC can be summarised in a few points: reduction of gas emissions, expansion of renewable energy, decarbonisation and investment in research and innovation. Despite the ambitious plan, Italy has been criticised for delays in implementing it. Moreover, it still relies on natural gas, which undermines its decarbonisation goals.
Since its commitments have not been found sufficient by activists and analysts, many are taking to the streets to show their dissatisfaction. Generally, they use forms of pacific protest to draw attention to the country's environmental crisis and politicians’ inaction against this threat.
Considering the last few years, the main environmental group is Last generation (Ultima Generazione in Italian), which started demonstrating in December 2021, mainly blocking streets in Rome.
In July 2022, in Florence, members of the same group glued themselves to the frame’s glass that protected Botticelli’s work named La Primavera. No actual damage was caused to the painting, yet many proclaimed words of condemnation.
In November 2022, activists of the Group Last Generation targeted Van Gogh’s The Sower during its temporary exhibition at Palazzo Bonaparte in Rome, staining the painting’s protective glass with vegetable soup. They then chained themselves to the wall and shouted slogans against the use of carbon in the Italian industry.
In May 2023, after a devastating flooding that hit Emilia Romagna, killing at least 14 people and displacing thousands, two members of the group Ultima Generazione (Last Generation) smeared themselves with mud as a symbolic protest against the government’s inadequate response.
As it can be seen, those demonstrations are mainly pacific, with activists refraining from violence and causing minimal or no damage to property and infrastructure.
2. United Kingdom
The UK's climate continues to change with recent decades warmer, wetter and sunnier than the 20th century. Observations show that extremes of temperature in the UK have been affected much more than average temperature.
The UK's second warmest year (2023) and the warmest June and the September heatwave were consequences of climate change.
2023 was the second warmest year on record for the UK in the series from 1884, with only 2022 being warmer. 2023 was 0.83°C above the 1991–2020 average and 1.66°C above 1961–1990. Moreover, out of the top-ten warmest years in the UK since 1884, six belong to the most recent decade (2014–2023), with all 10 warmest years occurring in the 21st century.
Only recently, the British government introduced a moratorium on fracking and announced plans to phase out coal (The Guardian, 2024). However, explorations and extractions of onshore oil and gas and coal have continued.
In 2024, the last coal fired power plant in the United Kingdom closed; however, a strong need remains to end gas extraction. Even if coal was eliminated, other fossil fuels remain unquestioned.
The government has declared it would expand deployment of renewable energy and storage, and implementation of such intention is needed. In 2022, Ccpi reports, the former government developed the North Sea Transition Deal together with the oil and gas industries (Ccpi, 2024). The policy plan aims to maximise the advantages for the UK’s oil and gas sector from the global shift to clean growth. The UK’s Climate Change Committee (CCC) criticised this, pointing out the plan’s targets as being ‘significantly lower’ than what is required to meet the UK’s carbon budget. The targets only cover upstream emissions from extraction. The CCPI experts see potential for the new government to strengthen the country’s policy on fossil fuel extraction and abolish subsidies for it.
Moreover, the UK is home to some of the biggest polluters and oil producers in the world such as Shell and British Petroleum. On the other hand, a strong conscience and a strong record of environmental movements can be tracked dating back to the 60s and 70s. Taking into consideration a more recent period of time, different phases can be traced. A first one starts in 2010 and lasted approximately until 2014. In this period environmental activism consisted in small and local groups gathered in rural areas and carrying on anti-fracking activities. In the following phase, that began in 2018, those local campaign groups started to increase closeness with each other, which led to beneficial exchanges in terms of strategies and support. In this period, a common strategy was to appeal to the UK Secretary of State to call in decisions made by local councils. In even more recent times, since climate change goals became more and more urgent for nations and governments, several movements gained momentum and they were able to go beyond local borders, becoming internationally known.
Climate activism in the UK took different shapes according to the movement and the extent of the action, and varied among different types of strategies. Regarding the tactics used, recurring to massive city blockade has increased, reaching its climax in 2018 and 2019 when for some days London was blocked by a massive protest organised by Extinction Rebellion (XR).
Another instrument was the organisation of “climate camps” or camps for climate action. The first English edition was held in 2006 and it was meant to be a space where environmental and social priorities were negotiated. It was also a place to share knowledge, techniques and to organise actions. In the following years, recurring to climate camps became a practice held all over Europe and beyond. This underlines the importance of networking, both with other environmental activists and with other social groups or social movements (e.g. workers).
Activists also recurred to legal actions, by critical actionship and climate trials. In the latter, they made a civic denouncement of fossil fuels companies. The request was to make them accountable - in both financial and moral sense - of the climate crisis. Another widely used tool to foster moral sense is through petitions. In the previous years, petitions were mainly used to make requests to the government, asking to “let the communities” decide on the use of public spaces and natural resources. Currently, they are mostly used to avoid any involvement from big companies in public institutions or to demand authorities and organisations to cut ties with such companies. For example, manifesting in front of a new coal fired power plant or new infrastructures that are considered responsible to erode the environment or cause massive emissions. These kinds of petitions are often coupled with direct action that aims to slow or block the factories. For instance, the “Reclaim power” campaign was a one-day campaign where people took action against power stations, to demand to move away from a fossil fuel economy.
One very famous case in recent years is the Extinction rebellion network, which originated in London, from ideas and studies by Roger Hallam and Dr Gail Bradbrook. The first public activity was held in London on 31st october, 2018, underling the urgence to act in order to stop the climate collapse. (Extinction Rebellion, 2018). The fundative “Declaration of Urgence” led to the first massive climate march, that gathered 10 thousand people in London. The initiative targeted important national buildings (Parliament square, Waterloo bridge, Oxford circus, Marble arch) “challenging and disrupting Business-as-Usual that has headed to extinction”. (Extinction Rebellion, 2018). Their key demand was to “tell the truth” and “act now” by reducing greenhouse gas emissions. Mass demonstrations eventually led the Parliament to declare a “Climate emergency”. The network counts 130 groups in the UK and over one thousand national, regional and local groups all over the world. “We declared ourselves in Rebellion against the Government for its criminal inaction on tackling climate breakdown and ecological collapse” stated the declaration (Extinction Rebellion, 2018).
Their action was focused, at least in the first phase, on a call to urgency and immediate risk, with an approach characterised by attention to security matters and protection of activists; non-violent disobedience, decentralisation and inclusive participation to avoid hierarchies. Consensus was also at the core of collective actions, decided during inclusive assemblies. Another key aspect adopted by Extinction Rebellion was the distinction into risk groups (sectors of the mobilisation with different levels of risk). Moreover, they structured a legal strategy, outlined in their public website, in order to have a clear and strong response in case of arrest, trial and judicial action against activists.
3. Denmark
Being made up of islands and peninsulas, Denmark is highly affected by the effects of climate change. According to the International Energy Agency, the country’s average annual temperature has risen by 1.5°C since 1870, a rate which is slightly higher than the global average. This led to more frequent heat waves and droughts during spring and summer times, a phenomenon which was so diffuse in relatively cool and wet countries like Denmark. At the same time, annual precipitation has increased by 20%, heightening the risks of flooding, storms and cloudbursts.
Denmark is undoubtedly a frontrunner when it comes to combat climate change, but despite having high ambitions, research indicates that it is failing to reach its emission reduction goals set out in the 2020 Climate Act. This act sets a target to reduce greenhouse gases by 70% in 2030 compared to 1990 levels and achieve climate neutrality by 2050, at the latest.
For many Danes, climate change and its consequences on their lives and lifestyles are pressing concerns that their politicians must adequately address.
Environmental demonstrations in Denmark have a long history, with one of the main ones occurring in 2009, just before the COP15 conference that took place in Copenhagen.
After the 2019 European elections, known as the climate elections, given the importance of climate change for voters, candidates, and political parties, many Danes decided to take the streets to demand real actions against climate change and criticise the lack of radical transformation. Within civil society, some started realising that demonstrations were not enough to prompt their government action.
A prominent association is the one named Extinction Rebellion, a large group that rebels against and criticises the Danish government for its inaction regarding the climate and ecological crisis that is occurring. The group started protesting in 2019. The first action occurred in February in Copenhagen, the capital, and Aarhus, the second-most-populated city. The protesters blocked trucks directed to Aarhus oil harbour. This way of protesting has been used for a long time in Denmark. They blocked car traffic the following year by chaining themselves to a movable boat.
During the same year, members of the group Baltic Pipe Nej Tak occupied an expropriated house and broke into construction sites to protest the construction of a gas pipeline. These acts reflect growing frustration and a demand for more urgent climate action.
4. Germany
Germany has seen its number of extremely hot days increase across the last decades. For example, the number of days where temperature exceeded 30 degrees Celsius (86 degrees Fahrenheit) has risen from three to eight dre per year, with glaciers melting and rivers shrinking. Also the biggest cities, like Berlin and Hamburg, were hit by major impacts. Extreme heat, powerful storms and concerns related to public health and food security are currently the most urgent challenges for the country.
During 2024, Germany dropped two places in the Climate change performance index (Ccpi), rating “medium” in some areas like greenhouse gas emissions, renewable energy, climate policy and energy use. The country has recorded some achievements in the energetic transition and in renewable energy, nevertheless though budget constraints persist and its industries are still responsible for too many emissions.
In recent times, environmental movements in Germany have become more radical in demands, focusing on fossil fuels phase-out and claiming the end of expansion of mining sites. Their action is determined to shut down plants and carbon mining sites. Movements like Ende Gelände (Ende Gelände, literally end of terrain, is a common phrase in German to say "Time is up" or "Enough is enough") put civil disobedience at their core and mobilised thousands of people in the last ten years. The framing concept for the birth and success of these movements is that Germany still hosts a lot of active coal mining sites and has not taken significant steps in tackling climate change and commitment to green transition. One famous case was the Hambach one, an open sky lignite mining site in the North-Rhein Westfalia region. For years, from 2015 to 2019 to be specific, activists occupied the forest around the site and coal plant, in order to slow and possibly stop the exploitation. In 2018, they occupied the Hambach forest, which was under deforestation threat, in order to expand the mining site. The activists built houses on trees and were able to stay there for months, until eventually evicted by the police. However, later on, the evictment was declared illegal, and the deforestation was stopped. Another region where lots of demonstrations take place is Lusazia and Leipzig, home to steel, lignite and coal mining projects, often related to the German energy multinational Rwe.
The action is often divided into smaller groups, called “fingers” that are scaled according to the intensity of the action. This has a double scope: on the one side, it allows the group to diversify and hit multiple sites at the same time; on the other side, it allows participants to choose the level of intensity they want to engage with.
Political regulation
As environmental demonstrations spread in Europe, the governments are developing new responses. Even though they rarely committed serious acts of vandalism or clashed with law enforcement, many democratic countries are enacting harsh laws and using punitive measures to crack down on activists. This is the main finding of a report released in September by the Climate Rights International (CRI). According to the organisation, authorities are imposing prison sentences, engaging also in preventive detention. The report underlines how the punishments imposed on activists are often disproportionate in relation to their actions (CRI, 2024).
The repression, criminalisation, and stigmatisation of climate activism is noted also by the Council of Europe’s commissioner for human rights, Dunja Mijatović, who “expressed concerns at the shrinking space for freedom of peaceful assembly and the threats facing environmental activism in Europe” (Dunja Mijatović, 2023). In her statement, she urged public authorities to ensure that everyone can use their right to freedom of peaceful assembly and expression safely (ibidem).
Dunja Mijatović’s criticisms and exhortations have been reiterated by other organisations and public figures. Michel Forst, former Special Rapporteur on human rights defenders, said that the repression faced by climate activists is a major threat to democracy. In particular, he focused on the attempt of some governments, like the Spanish one, to label environmental activism as extremism. By categorising it as a potential threat to security and by limiting freedom of expression, the vitality of democratic societies is at risk (Laville, 2024).
This second part of the article describes the actions of some governments aimed at limiting civil protests.
1. Italy
Italian authorities are implementing preventive measures to curb climate demonstrations. Two meaningful examples are the so-called rimpatrio con foglio di via, a city ban lasting from six months up to four years, and the daspo urbano, which prohibits access to specific areas for periods ranging from 48 hours up to two years. Yet, both measures are questionable in relation to their constitutionality due to the lack of process and the principle of proportionality. In fact, according to the Italian constitution process is mandatory in those cases in order to avoid arbitrary applications of banning measures. Moreover, there must be a balance between the sanction imposed and the violation committed. Yet, those solutions seem to inflict a punishment disproportionate to the minimal threat posed by climate activists to public security.
The current government has enacted two major laws targeting environmental activists and limiting non-violent demonstration rights.
The first is the so-called eco-vandalism law, approved by the Chamber of Deputies, the lower house of the Italian Parliament, in January 2024. Its main targets are ecologist groups, like Ultima Generazione, which have organised multiple demonstrations and actions.
Article 1 of said law imposes fines ranging from 20.000 to 60.000 euros on anyone who renders cultural and landscape assets unusable. Additionally, it changes two articles of the penal code, articles 635 and 639 to increase punishments. Under Article 3, “anyone who destroys or deteriorates or renders unusable someone else’s movable or immovable property during events taking place in a public space or in a place open to the public is punished with imprisonment from one to five years and with a fine of up to 10.000 euros” (Normattiva, 2024). If the offence occurs in museums or art galleries, the perpetrator risks imprisonment from one month to six months and a fine of up to 1000 euros.
More recently, on September 18, the Italian government passed a controversial security law that has been highly criticised by the opposition parties, analysts, and social activists, since it is seen as an attempt to reprime dissent and diminish the space for free speech and criticism against the government. This decree increases repression in several fields. For example, it targets anyone who decides to carry out passive resistance in prison or centres for migrants. It also penalises anyone who demonstrates against two strategic infrastructures, the high-speed Turin-Lyon railway and the bridge over the Strait of Messina, both strongly supported by Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Infrastructure Matteo Salvini.
However, the main target appears to be the climate movements, which some politicians have labelled as “climate terrorists.” According to the government, this new measure is intended to prevent problematic situations like the one that occurred in April in the city of Turin during the G7 reunion. On that occasion, the Group of Seven met to discuss the climate agendas of those Nations, and many protesters decided to block a highway to show their opposition.
Under this new law, anyone who blocks a road for a demonstration, the most common tactic used by climate activists, could face up to two years in prison. It also increases penalties for those resisting police.
2. United Kingdom
In the UK, the government's reaction to climate activists is twofold: one is to counter-narrative activities and ideologies; the other one is to produce tailored-laws that affect people involved in such activities. Regarding the former, it is all about making the action seem violent, underlying negative effects like traffic- blockade and possible damages to residents. In other cases, the discourse is about the moral value of damaging a public good, like shops, plants or statues, underlying how negative it is to damage public spaces. Another strategy is to give activists reduced media-coverage, in order to disregard their actions and message. Finally, another narrative commonly used to tackle the environmental demands is by counter replying with social demands, especially with job-related topics.. For example, in 2011 the conservative UK premier David Cameron used to say that new fossil fuel plants would lead to more jobs and provide money to small and local neighbourhoods, undermining activists' demands.
Moreover, a new legal framework has been introduced to undermine those kinds of actions. Even though there are no laws explicitly targeted to “environmental action”, a couple of laws to increase repression have been documented, including an increment in police violence under the authorisation of the state, and agents undercover attending meetings and entering in relationships with activists.
Environmental protesters have often been placed in pre-trial detention, including solitary confinement, or have been given hard or expensive bail conditions like curfews, electronic ankle tags and restriction to travel or to attend social meetings. In other cases, they were imprisoned for peaceful protests, like slow marches or for blocking a bridge.
Legally speaking, as documented by the special UN rapporteur for climate defenders, courts have prohibited environmental protesters from putting forward defences based on necessity or proportionality, and have forbidden protesters from mentioning climate change, thereby preventing them from explaining the reasons for their protest. In some cases, also the UN rapporteurs describe, some were denied to challenge their sentence by the Supreme Court. This happens while companies - some of them owned or controlled by the state - take on civil injunctions against protesters.
3. Denmark
The criminalisation of climate activists started in 2009 when the government passed a law that granted more power to the police. Thanks to this law, police could arrest people in proximity of illegal protests and could detain activists for up to 12 hours. The fines were also augmented, and obstructing police work was reclassified from a finable offence to one punishable by up to 40 days in jail.
At the beginning, activists were charged with violating traffic laws, since they created problems on the streets. Those laws were not part of the criminal code; therefore, they only carried small fines. Police also tried to charge protesters with violation of the criminal code 119 which condemns whoever blocks the police’s work to a fine or to imprisonment for up to eight years (Europam. 2005) However, establishing if such a violation occurred in several cases proved to be difficult.
The situation escalated in 2022, when the police began invoking Article 193 of the Penal Code, which states that “anyone who, in an unlawful manner, causes major disturbances in the operation of public means of transport (...) shall be liable to a fine or to imprisonment for any terms not exceeding six years” (Europam, 2005) Yet, it seems that the application of this article is more of a blatant attempt to criminalise and increase the repression of non-violent climate activists. In fact, more than twenty-two activista have been charged under the penal code, but no one was actually sent to jail.
Jailing activists has increasingly been used as a form of repression, and the conditions in which they are forced to stay during their detention are deteriorating. For example, in May 2022, 238 people were arrested for civil disobedience. One detainee claimed he was denied a phone call, warm clothes, and toilet use while detained (De Rosa e Kruse , 2024).
UNECE, the United Nations Economic Commission for Europe, has highlighted further abuses, noting that protesters are often denied access to medication or medical care (Frost, 2024). In other cases, they are also sometimes subjected to full-strip research. All those practices violate international law. In fact, according to Article 10 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR), signed in 1966, “all persons deprived of their liberty shall be treated with humanity and with respect for the inherent dignity of the human person” (OHCHR, 1966). Additionally, the European Convention on Human Rights (CEDU) states that “no one shall be subjected to torture or to inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment” (CEDU, 1953).
The threat to put people in prison is a straightforward attempt to try to limit and reprime demonstrations. Rarely, after being accused, activists go to court, and the few times it happened, they managed to avoid being sent to prison.
Interestingly, in 2022, the Danish Security and Intelligence Service (PET) included climate extremists on the list of terrorist threats to Denmark. Yet, PET itself acknowledged that there are no climate extremist groups in Denmark who are willing to use violence in their fight.
4. Germany
The German framework for punishment of environmental protesters includes both negative rhetoric and legal and police repression.
On the one side, there is criminalization rhetoric.By using a certain language, for example in the definition of terrorists, radicals, annoying, and violent, to refer to climate activists contributes to defining their image as criminals. Limited press freedom during demonstrations and reduced media coverage on the reasons and voice of activists is also common.
On the other hand, police actions have become harder and harder in the last years, with violent evictions in the case of occupied forests, sites and roads. The use of the cattle method (surrounding activists with no place to escape) became widespread. In some cases, activists say that they were put on buses and brought to police stations in remote locations, without any information about the location and with an intimidatory approach. The use of horses, dogs, water cannons, pepper spray and baton strikes were documented. Police brutality is also an element, like what happened in 2023 in Luzerath where several head injuries in demonstrators were recorded. (UN special rapporteur report, 2024)
In 2024, a nationwide raid was carried out in Bavaria on behalf of the Bavarian State Office of Criminal Investigation and the Central Office for Combating Terrorism and Extremism. Fifteen homes and business locations of members of the Last Generation were searched. This was possible due to the accusation of forming a criminal organisation.
Also targeted arrests, ordered to deprive groups of their leaderships, are commonly used in Germany. Criminalisation of blockade has become more and more frequent in recent years: it is common practice to record personal details and initiate proceedings for coercion during similar actions, quoting the exercise of force to compel or restrict someone. About two years ago, first-time participation in a sit-in blockade was punishable by a fine of 20 daily rates, today it is often 120 daily rates. Some changes in law were introduced in order to make prosecution harsher and intensify penalties. It has been approved the use of investigation and surveillance measures on environmental defenders, the same applied to criminal organisations, and courts have adopted preventive detention and high bail conditions. For example, the authorities are prosecuting the climate movement Last Generation on the charge of forming a criminal organisation, implying that they intend to commit serious crimes threatening public safety. In 2024, Ende Gelände was also classified as a suspected left-wing extremist case by the Office of protection of the Constitution (UN special rapporteur, 2024).
As the UN rapporteur recalls in a 2024 report this has a concrete impact on members of the movement as the charge allows for far-reaching powers of investigation, such as telephone-tapping, geolocating and property searches (UN special rapporteur, 2024).
The consequence of targeting movements as criminal organisations also means that making donations to the movement can no longer be an option, because it can be considered as financing a criminal organisation.
Conclusion
Extreme weather events are increasing and climate change is threatening economies, societies and lives. Therefore, in civil society concerns have increased about the threats of climate change and in recent years environmental movements became central. This paper aimed to describe how they are organised and how they are threatened by authorities. In order to understand the phenomenon, four countries have been taken into consideration: Italy, the United Kingdom, Denmark and Germany,
The conclusion coming from this research is that movements share the same ideas and demands, which are often considered not as a national problem but as a global challenge. Secondly, governments show a common path in reaction to these movements and in increasing repression. Laws with similar characteristics are issued, with the common goal to silence protest and to undermine environmental protests. A similar narrative has been adopted, with the tracked-use of similar definitions in all the examined countries, such as “terrorists” and “vandals”.
In conclusion, a common path toward criminalisation of environmental activists and defenders can be seen and there is space to further examination of this kind, including other case studies.
Classification of sources
Information content | ||
1 | Confirmed | Confirmed by other independent sources; logical in itself; coherent with other information on the topic |
2 | Presumably true | Not confirmed; logical in itself; coherent with other information on the topic |
3 | Maybe true | Not confirmed; reasonably logical in itself; coherent with some other information on the topic |
4 | Uncertain | Not confirmed; possible but not logical in itself; no other information on the topic |
5 | Improbable | Not confirmed; not logical in itself; contradicts with other information on the topic |
6 | Not able to be evaluated | No basis for evaluating the validity of the information |
Trustworthiness of the source | ||
A | Trustworthy | No doubt about authenticity, reliability or competence; has a history of total trustworthiness |
B | Normally trustworthy | Small doubts about authenticity, reliability or competence, nevertheless have a history of valid information in a majority of cases |
C | Sufficiently trustworthy | Doubts about authenticity, reliability or competence; however, has supplied valid information in the past |
D | Normally not trustworthy | Significant doubts about authenticity, reliability or competence, however, has supplied valid information in the past |
E | Not trustworthy | Lack of authenticity, reliability or competence; history of invalid information |
F | Not able to be evaluated | No basis for evaluating the validity of the information |
Bibliography
- Anderson, J.G. (1990). “‘Environmentalism,’‘New Politics’ and Industrialism: Some Theoretical Perspectives. Scandinavian Political Studies 13: 101–18. B2
- Antonaki A. (2024), “Italy alert: concerning civic space repressions”, CivicSpaceWatch. Accessible at: “https://civicspacewatch.eu/italy-alert-concerning-civic-space-repressions/ B2
- Barry, J. and Doherty, B. (2001) “The Greens and Social Policy: Movements, Politics and Practice?”, Social Policy and Administration 35(5): 587-601. B1
- Berglund, O. (2024) “In the UK, a dangerous escalation in the criminalization of climate protests”. Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists. Accessible at: In the UK, a dangerous escalation in the criminalization of climate protests - Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists B1
- Camp for Climate Action (2006) “Direct Action at the Climate Camp”, Accessible at: http://web.archive.org/web/20060813140119/www.climatecamp.org.uk/reclaimpower.htm#drax B2
- CEDU (1953), “European Convention on Human Rights”, ECHR. Accessible at: https://www.echr.coe.int/documents/d/echr/convention_ENG A1
- Climate change performance index (Ccpi) Climate Change Performance Index (CCPI) A1
- Cnn (2024) “Just Stop Oil demanded climate action. Their protests have landed them in prison”, CNN. Accessible at: Just Stop Oil demanded climate action. Their protests have landed them in prison | CNN B1
- CRI (2024), “CRI climate protesters report. On thin ice - Disproportionate responses to climate change protesters in democratic countries”, CRI. Accessible at: https://cri.org/reports/on-thin-ice/#elementor-toc__heading-anchor-1 A1
- De Rosa S. P. and Kruse G. (2024), “The Danish way to criminalize climate activism”, Undisciplined Environments. Accessible at: https://undisciplinedenvironments.org/2024/03/25/the-danish-way-to-criminalize-climate-activism/ B2
- Deutsche Welle (2024) “Climate protest halts Frankfurt flights” https://www.dw.com/embed/480/av-69768634 ; https://www.dw.com/en/frankfurt-airport-climate-activists-stop-scores-of-flights/a-69760006#:~:text=A%20protest%20at%20Germany's%20largest,a%20full%20week%20of%20protests.&text=The%20Last%20Generation%20climate%20group,causing%20the%20suspension%20of%20flights. A1
- Deutsche Welle (2024) “Germany's Last Generation aims to revive climate protests” https://www.dw.com/en/germanys-last-generation-group-aims-to-revive-climate-protests/a-69767159#:~:text=Young%20Germans%20fighting%20for%20climate%20agenda&text=In%20response%20to%20widespread%20harsh,indicate%20a%20change%20of%20mind. A1
- ECCO (2024), “Piano nazionale integrato per l’energia e il clima (PNIEC), La pagella di Ecco”. Ecco. Accessible at: https://eccoclimate.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/PNIEC_La-pagella-di-ECCO.pdf B2
- EU (2023), “Climate change”, EU. Accessible at: https://europa.eu/eurobarometer/surveys/detail/2954 A1
- Europam (2005), “The Criminal Code”, Europam. Accessible at: https://europam.eu/data/mechanisms/PF/PF%20Laws/Denmark/Denmark_Criminal_Code_2005.pdf A1
- Extinction Rebellion (2018), “Declaration of Rebellion”, Extinction Rebellion UK. Accessible at: https://extinctionrebellion.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/XR-A3-declaration-V1.pdf B1
- Extinction Rebellion (2018), “Legal Info”, Extinction Rebellion UK. Accessible at: Legal Info - Extinction Rebellion UK B2
- Extinction Rebellion (2024), “About”, Extinction Rebellion UK. Accessible at: https://extinctionrebellion.uk/about/ B1
- Forst, M. (2024) “State repression of environmental protest and civil disobedience: a major threat to human rights and democracy”. Position Paper by Un Special Rapporteur on Environmental Defenders under the Aarhus Convention Accessible at: UNSR_EnvDefenders_Aarhus_Position_Paper_Civil_Disobedience_EN.pdf A1
- Frost M. (2024), “State repression of environmental protest and civil disobedience: a major threat to human rights and democracy”, UNECE. Accessible at: https://unece.org/sites/default/files/2024-02/UNSR_EnvDefenders_Aarhus_Position_Paper_Civil_Disobedience_EN.pdf A1
- Gayle D. (2022), “Climate activists in Italy glue themselves to Botticelli Painting”, The Guardian. Accessible at: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/jul/22/climate-activists-in-italy-glue-themselves-to-botticelli-painting A1
- Giugni, M., Grasso, M. (2015). “Environmental Movements in Advanced Industrial Democracies: Heterogeneity, Transformation, and Institutionalization”, Review in Advance. Vol. 40:337-361 (Volume publication date November 2015). Accessible at: https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-environ-102014-021327 B2
- Greenpeace (2024), “Con il DDL sicurezza il governo reprime il dissenso e la resistenza passiva”, Greenpeace. Accesible at: https://www.greenpeace.org/italy/storia/24892/con-il-ddl-sicurezza-il-governo-reprime-il-dissenso-e-la-resistenza-passiva/ B2
- Hielscher, S., Wittmayer, J., Dańkowska, A. (2022), "Social movements in energy transitions: The politics of fossil fuel energy pathways in the United Kingdom, the Netherlands and Poland”. The Extractive Industries and Society, Volume 10, 2022, 101073, ISSN 2214-790X. Accessible at: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.exis.2022.101073 B2
- Hofmann L. (2024), “A Climate of Fear! An Overview of the Criminalization of Climate Justice Activism in Germany (Part I)”, Undisciplined Environments. Accessible at: A Climate of Fear! An Overview of the Criminalization of Climate Justice Activism in Germany (Part I) - Undisciplined Environments B1
- Holms K. (2024), “Criminalising climate activism: Recent trends”, ClimaTalk. Accessible at: https://climatalk.org/2024/09/09/criminalising-climate-activism-recent-trends/ B2
- Huding K. (2023), “French government steps up repression after bloody battle of Sainte-Soline”, StateWatch. Accessible at: https://www.statewatch.org/news/2023/may/french-government-steps-up-repression-after-bloody-battle-of-sainte-soline/ B2
- Huges R. A. (2024), “European governments are using ‘hars, overly broad’ laws to silence climate protesters”, Euronews. Accessible at: https://www.euronews.com/green/2024/09/11/european-governments-are-using-harsh-overly-broad-laws-to-silence-climate-protesters B1
- IEA (2022), “Italy's climate resilience policy indicator”, IEA. Accessible at: https://www.iea.org/articles/italy-climate-resilience-policy-indicator A1
- IlSole24Ore (2024), “Carcere fino a 5 anni: è legge la stretta sugli ecovandali”, IlSole24Ore. Accessible at: https://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/carcere-fino-5-anni-e-legge-stretta-ecovandali-AFUXp9NC A1
- Laville S. (2024), “European nations must end repression of peaceful climate protest, says UN expert”, The Guardian. Accessible at: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2024/feb/28/european-nations-must-end-repression-of-peaceful-climate-protest-says-un-expert B1
- Letzte Generation (2024), “Who we are”, Letzte Generation. Accessible at: https://letztegeneration.org/en/wer-wir-sind/ B1
- Mijatović D. (2023), “Crackdowns on peaceful environmental protests should stop and give way to more social dialogue”, Council Of Europe Portal. Accessible at: https://www.coe.int/en/web/commissioner/-/crackdowns-on-peaceful-environmental-protests-should-stop-and-give-way-to-more-social-dialogue A1
- NOAH (2024), “Under pressure: repression of environmental activism in Denmark 2019-2024”, NOAH. Accessible at: https://noah.dk/sites/default/files/2024-10/Fri%20rapport%20web.pdf B2
- Normattiva (2024), “LEGGE 22 gennaio 2024, n. 6”, Normattiva. Accessible at: https://www.normattiva.it/uri-res/N2Ls?urn:nir:stato:legge:2024-01-22;6 A1
- OHCHR (1966), “International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights”, OHCHR. Accessible at: https://www.ohchr.org/en/instruments-mechanisms/instruments/international-covenant-civil-and-political-rights A1
- Rawcliffe, P. (1995). “Making Inroads: Transport Policy and the British Environmental” Movement. Environment: Science and Policy for Sustainable Development, 37(3), 16–36. Accessible at: https://doi.org/10.1080/00139157.1995.9929227 B2
- Roberts H. and Di Sario D. (2024), “Meloni’s street protest crackdown prompts concerns of growing repression in Italy”, Politico. Accessible at: https://www.politico.eu/article/giorgia-meloni-street-protest-crackdown-concerns-growing-repression-italy-security-bill-climate-activists/ B1
- Rootes, C., Miller, A. (2000), University of Kent at Canterbury, “The British environmental movement: organisational field and network organisation” B2
- Schlembach, R. (2011). “How do radical climate movements negotiate their environmental and their social agendas? A study of debates within the Camp for Climate Action (UK)”. Critical Social Policy, 31(2), 194-215. Accessible at: https://doi.org/10.1177/0261018310395922 B2
- SkyTG24 (2022), “Da Van Gogh a Monet, le proteste contro l’arte degli attivisti di Ultima Generazione”, SkyTG24. Accessible at: https://tg24.sky.it/ambiente/2022/11/15/ultima-generazione-attivisti-arte#03 B2
- SkyTg24 (2023), “Imbrattano quadro di Van Gogh, quattro attiviste di Ultima Generazione a processo”, SkyTG24. Accessible at: https://tg24.sky.it/cronaca/2023/04/20/attivisti-ultima-generazione-quadro-van-gogh-roma B2
- The Climate Reality Project (2024), “How the climate crisis is impacting Italy”, The Climate Reality Project. Accessible at: https://www.climaterealityproject.org/blog/how-climate-crisis-impacting-italy B2
- The Guardian (2024), “End of an era as Britain’s last coal-fired power plant shuts down” https://www.theguardian.com/business/2024/sep/30/end-of-an-era-as-britains-last-coal-fired-power-plant-shuts-down B2
- The Guardian (2024) “UK climate activists convicted in first trial of new anti-protest laws” UK climate activists convicted in first trial of new anti-protest laws | UK news | The Guardian A1
- Vanhala, L. (2012) “Legal Opportunity Structures and the Paradox of Legal Mobilization by the Environmental Movement in the UK”, Law & Society Review, Volume 46 , Issue 3, September 2012 , pp. 523 - 556. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-5893.2012.00505.x B2
- Weise Z. (2023), “Europe’s climate activists face ‘repressive tide’”, Politico.eu. Accessible at: https://www.politico.eu/article/europe-governments-crackdown-climate-change-activists-action-last-generation-extinction-rebellion/ B1
Riproduzione Riservata Ⓡ