Abstract:
We live in a contradictory era. This is because on the one hand states are striving to reduce carbon dioxide emissions, phase out fossil fuel usage, and move toward a green economy. Paradoxically, meanwhile, they continue to increase subsidies for fossil fuels in their own countries. The drop in fossil fuel prices and overall energy demand, slashed fossil fuel subsidies to a record low of around USD 180 billion in 2020. Compared to 2019, this represents a 40% reduction, and the lowest value ever recorded by the International Energy Agency, since they started monitoring these subsidies back in 2007 (IEA, 2021). Nevertheless, in 2021, these subsidies rebounded to USD 440 billion, roughly matching 2018 levels. This was largely linked to the rise in energy prices and energy demand.
Theoretical Discussion:
In recent times the international community has redefined the international policy agenda to prioritize the issue of energy transition. Goal 12 of the 2030 Agenda seeks to overturn the logic of profit alone to educate citizens about responsible consumption and production, and to encourage initiatives that lead to a more sustainable future (Ritchie et. Al., 2018). For this reason, most countries have decided to commit themselves to provide and support incentives for investments in low-carbon technologies and services or for the production and consumption of “green” goods.
However, in a few cases, states opted for a completely different strategy: that of fossil fuel subsidies. This is a policy by which governments decide to impose a negative carbon tax to lower the price of fossil fuels. Clearly this makes them cheaper and, as a result, they end up by encouraging their production and use. Contrary to your expectations "energy subsidies are widespread" (UNEP, 2003). The question is why do some countries continue to provide subsidies for fossil fuels, instead of facilitating the transition to a clean energy economy?
Depending on the fuel and the country, this support may differ in importance and type. Global estimates by fuel type see Petroleum products in first place, followed by electricity, natural gas, and coal (FossilFuelSubsidyTracker, 2020). On the other side, according to the International Energy Agency, Iran supplied the largest amount of fossil fuel subsidies in 2020, followed by China and India (IEA, 2020).
The approach used by the OECD to assess the degree of support for the production and consumption of fossil fuels is largely based on two types of measures: the budgetary transfer and the tax expenditures (OECD, 2013).
Budgetary expenditures data shall be included in the State budget documents and they direct their attention mostly in three fields: support for energy purchases by low-income households; government expenditure on research, development, and demonstration projects; transfers to help redeploy resources in declining fossil-fuel industries, namely coal.
Tax expenditures are evaluated in reference to a given taxation system. They can be classified into three different areas: tax expenditures related to the final consumption of fossil fuels; tax expenditures related to the use of fossil fuels as inputs to production; tax expenditures related to the chain of production of fossil fuels (extraction, refining and transport).
On average, between 2017 and 2019, the G20 governments provided $ 584 billion annually via direct budgetary transfers and tax expenditure, price support, public finance, and SOE investment for the production and consumption of fossil fuels at home and abroad (Corkal et al. 2020 ). Compared to the period that goes from 2014 to 2016, the level of support fell by 9%. However, a third of this decrease occurred because of the drop in oil prices recorded during the COVID-19 crisis. Further, the decrease is not uniform across all the G20 countries, as some of them, such as Australia, Canada, China, France, India, Russia, and South Africa, have instead increased their support. The socio-economic consequences of the pandemic have prompted world's leading economies to pledge around $ 170 billion in public funds for fossil fuel-intensive sectors.
Case Study: China
The Asia-Pacific region is home to almost 60% of the world's population and it is the main driver of global economic growth. By far, Asia is also the largest emitter of carbon dioxide, accounting for 53% of global emissions. More than one-fourth of them comes from China, making this country Asia's and the world's top emitter (Ritchie & Roser, 2020). Global efforts to mitigate climate change will hinge on the degree to which Beijing and the entire Asia-Pacific region plan to decarbonize.
The Chinese government deems the development of the energy sector as pivotal for the country. Various strict regulations require State-owned enterprises to be involved at various stages of the supply chain, granting them monopoly power over the production, distribution, and consumption of fossil fuels. In this regard, energy subsidies have been a powerful tool for the Chinese government in shaping both the energy mix as well as the energy prices it sought.
If we look at China's energy mix , we can see that fossil fuels still account for the highest percentage. Over 62% of electricity is produced from coal, followed by hydro (17%), wind (6%), nuclear (5%) and solar (3%).
The People's Republic of China is the world's largest coal producer, accounting for 46.6% of the global total in 2019 (OECD, 2022). Despite its domestic production meeting most domestic needs, the country is also the world's largest coal importer. Over the same time span, China imported 234 million tonnes of coal, mostly from Australia and Indonesia, the world's two largest coal exporters. Lately, the government has also sought to develop unconventional hydrocarbons (such as shale gas and coal-field methane). This makes the country also heavily reliant on oil and natural gas. In 2020, the top 5 crude oil exporters to China, were Saudi Arabia, Russia, Iraq, Angola, and Brazil, which provided over half (58%) of China's demand (Workman, 2021). In terms of natural gas, Australia, Turkmenistan, Russia, Qatar, and the United States are its biggest suppliers (Ghosh, 2022). China's authorities are not too enthusiastic about this situation, and they are not keen on increasing its dependence on external suppliers, which is why increasing money is being invested in renewable energy.
The prices of fossil fuel are generally regulated by national, regional, and local authorities. Yet most segments of the energy market are regulated by the National Development and Reform Commission (NDRC) for both pricing and competition (OECD, 2022). Since 2016, the government has implemented a series of reforms aimed at further liberalizing gas and electricity prices. Regarding oil, the government has set a minimum price of 40 dollars per barrel and a maximum price of 130 dollars per barrel. As a result, when the international crude oil price falls below 40 dollars per barrel, the difference with the national minimum price is collected in a special "risk reserve fund", set up by the government to finance energy-saving programs and oil-quality improvement projects. Likewise, if the international oil price increases beyond USD 130 per barrel, the government will finance the oil companies from its reserve fund. Additionally, in 2019 the VAT rate for refined petroleum products lowered from 16% to 13% in 2019. A reduced VAT rate of 9% applies to fossil fuels used for heating and other residential purposes. (OECD, 2022)
According to the OECD Inventory of Support Measures for Fossil Fuels , China's financial support for fossil fuels in 2020 was estimated at CNY 193.72 billion: 83% of these were directed at end-users, whereas 17% were directed at firms. Direct transfers amount to CNY 150.30 billion, tax expenditures to CNY 43.41 billion. Compared to the trend recorded in previous years, direct transfers decreased by 33% from 2015 until now. On the other hand, tax expenditures rose from CNY 35.73 billion to CNY 43.41 billion.
The main means of supporting fossil fuels in China is through direct payments under the Petroleum Fuels Price-Reform Support Programs . In 2009, the NDRC moved from setting price ranges to setting price limits, which were directly affecting fuel users. This measure has mainly benefited taxi drivers, public transportation, and users of fuel in agriculture, forestry, and fisheries. This subsidy is set to gradually decrease every year. In 2019 it was reduced by 60% and further regulation will come after 2020. It was also not uncommon for the central government to financially compensate state-owned oil and gas companies like CNOOC, PetroChina, and Sinopec, when there were differences between domestic regulated prices and imports. (OECD, 2022)
During the pandemic, China intensified coal mining activities in Wuju, Pinliang, and Xinjiang. It also provided subsidies to air freight services and awards to airlines that insured their flights. As part of its economic stimulus program, it approved the construction of new coal-fired power plants in order to increase its electricity production capacity by 40 GW. In addition, a number of infrastructure projects for fossil fuels, including facilities for storing and receiving oil and gas, were approved. Some of these projects included the development of oil deposits and refined pipelines in Hunan Province and the construction of a new LNG reception station in the Beijing-Tianjin region, as well as one in Guandong province in China. (OECD, 2022)
Coal remains the biggest hurdle to the energy transition of China. According to the Global Subsidies Initiative, it is the most subsidized fuel in the country (IISD, 2015). This is bad because it means promoting the use of the most polluting energy source in the world, with all the side effects that come with it. Several activists have criticized the government strategy, contending that the damage caused by air pollution outweighs any subsidies. Not to mention that air pollution has disproportionate health effects on the poorer. (Early, 2017).
Xi Jinping's announcement of the dual carbon commitment of peaking carbon emissions by 2030 and reaching carbon neutrality only by 2060 was in fact extremely disheartening. Even though the dual carbon targets boosted activity in the renewables sector during 2021, the pledge to approach the energy transition is still too weak compared to the urgent actions required at international level to mitigate the effects of climate change. Based on the most recent information, China committed at least $ 27.14 billion supporting fossil fuel energy, and at least $ 20.46 billion supporting clean energy (EnergyPolicyTracker, 2020).
The estimated subsidies China provided for renewables in 2019 ranged between $ 1.1 billion and $ 13 billion, which is respectively 27 and 3 times less compared to the investments in the fossil fuels sector. (Herrero & Tagliaprieta, 2021). As fossil fuels' share of the energy mix needs to be drastically reduced, it makes no sense to subsidize them. In addition to being counterproductive, this energy policy strategy diverts resources away from other renewable energy subsidies, which could definitely be more effective.
Conclusion:
Energy price spikes demonstrate the importance of accelerating clean energy transitions rather than subsidizing fossil fuels. Fossil Fuel subsidies can improve energy affordability only apparently because depending on the type of fuel subsidy you may have different welfare impacts. In general, the poorest households which should benefit the most, end up taking less advantage from low energy prices compared to the richest part of the population. In the opinion of the IMF, it is a very inefficient policy which eventually imposes high fiscal costs that must be covered by merging higher public debt, higher tax burdens and the exclusion of productive public expenditure in relevant sectors like health, education of infrastructure (Coady et al., 2015).
Not to mention the negative impact that this strategy has on the environment. Fossil Fuel subsidies not only deter societies and companies from taking all the measures necessary to achieve the green transition, but in the short term they contribute to the increasing atmospheric greenhouse gas concentrations, nullifying all the efforts that the International Community is carrying on in bringing the CO2 level emissions back to pre-industrial level.
The economic impacts of the pandemic should not be used as a reason to increase government support for fossil fuels. Instead, in light of the existential threat of climate change, they should focus on developing sustainable energy infrastructure and creating green jobs. As a result, the UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) will be met, including SDG 12.c, which aims to "rationalize inefficient fossil-fuel subsidies that encourage wasteful consumption by removing market distortions, in accordance with national circumstances" and SDG 7 , which advocates that everyone should have access to affordable, reliable, sustainable, and modern energy (Ritchie et. al., 2018).
Author: Alessandra Colasanti
Acknowledgments:
Corkal et al., Doubling Back and Doubling Down: G20 Scorecard on Fossil Fuel Funding . International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD), 2020. [A-1] https://www.iisd.org/system/files/2020-11/g20-scorecard-report.pdf
Early, C., "Health Cost of China's Fossil Fuel Subsidies Highlighted." China Dialogue , 2017. [A-1]
https://chinadialogue.net/en/energy/9956-health-cost-of-china-s-fossil-fuel-subsidies-highlighted/ .
Energy Policy Tracker, 2021. [A-1]
https://www.energypolicytracker.org/country/china/ .
Fossil Fuel Subsidy Tracker, Fossil Fuel Subsidies , 2020. [A-1]
https://fossilfuelsubsidytracker.org/ .
García-Herrero, Tagliapietra (2021), "Asia-Pacific Must Phase out Fossil-Fuel Subsidies." BRINK . [A-1]
https://www.brinknews.com/asia-pacific-must-phase-out-fossil-fuel-subsidies/ .
Ghosh, "China Data: Total Natural Gas Imports Rose 20% in 2021 on Strong Energy Demand." S&P Global Commodity Insights , S&P Global Commodity Insights, 2022. [A-1]
Hannah Ritchie and Max Roser (2020) - "CO₂ and Greenhouse Gas Emissions". Published online at OurWorldInData.org, 2020. [A-1] https://ourworldindata.org/co2-and-other-greenhouse-gas-emissions
IISD, "Unpacking China's Fossil Fuel Subsidies." China | GSI , 2015. [A-1] https://www.iisd.org/gsi/faqs/china#:~:text=Coal%20is%20one%20of%20the,coal%2Dbased%20electricity%20in%202015
IEA, "Energy Subsidies - Topics." IEA , 2021.
https://www.iea.org/topics/energy-subsidies .
OECD, Inventory of Estimated Budgetary Support and Tax Expenditures for Fossil Fuels 2013 , OECD Publishing, Paris, 2013. [A-1]
https://doi.org/10.1787/9789264187610-en .
OECD, OECD Inventory of Support Measures for Fossil Fuels: Country Notes , OECD Publishing, Paris, 2022.
https://doi.org/10.1787/5a3efe65-en .
Ritchie, et al., "Measuring progress towards the Sustainable Development Goals." SDG-Tracker.org, website, 2018. [A-1] https://sdg-tracker.org/sustainable-consumption-production#12.C
UNEP (United Nations Environment Program), Energy Subsidies: Lessons Learned in Assessing their impact and designing Policy reforms. 1sted. 2003. [A-1]
Workman, D., "Top 15 Crude Oil Suppliers to China." World's Top Exports , 2021. [B-1] https://www.worldstopexports.com/top-15-crude-oil-suppliers-to-china/