How is the current Biden administration's climate policy strategy comparable to the former Trump administration?

  Focus - Allegati
  09 April 2022
  14 minutes, 36 seconds

Abstract:

Throughout the past few years, the changes in the United States administration has procured mass distinctions in policy building. Between the conservative viewpoints of Donald Trump to the liberal ideology of Biden, there could not be a more distinct comparison of government politics. More specifically, climate policy has seen massive shifts under both administrations. From president Trump’s abandonment of the Paris Agreement and anti-environment legislation to Biden’s cooperative perspectives on the Paris Agreement with the countries re-approval of it, we see the sharp contrasts in party ideology in the United States political system.

General Discussion and Hypothesis:

The mass distinction between the actions of both Trump and Biden can be attributed to the use of partisanship in the domestic politics of the United States. Domestic level factors of partisanship in the United States is a driving factor for the discrepancies between the Trump and Biden administration's approach towards climate policy and environmental implications. The Biden administration shows the strict divide of ideology regarding diplomacy in domestic politics. Democrat values from public pressures are apparent and influential in his approach towards the allegiance towards the Paris Agreement in the form of cooperation and an emphasis on alliances in the international sector. The contrast between this approach and the Trump approach is stagnant. The approach towards climate policy of the Trump administration was influenced by the republican ideals of the direct promotion of the United States security, economic growth, and interests through isolationism.

Democratic ideals and republican ideals influence both of the President’s approach towards international climate agreements in a significant way. With the introduction of new, younger democrats such as Alexandria Ocasio Cortez into the congressional sector, the environment has been a motivating factor that has affected young people’s legitimacy in their voters choice. Democrats understand their target audience in today’s changing world and have developed mechanisms in order to satisfy and motivate their ability to get re-elected. Young people have been more ‘green’ in today’s standard than in previous generations. This contrast is heavily dictated when studying the republican approach towards the environment. The republican party does indeed support environmental conservation, yet it must address the factor of economics. The conservative effort to uphold the environment must be in the economical parameters which republicans deem sufficient. Unfortunately, in today’s political climate, republican environmental ideals are being scrutinized due to their support for the fossil fuel industry. Democrats have since criticized this position, citing that the republican party deems environmental conservation a not important subject to uphold.

The position of the analysis presented above leads to the question of “How is the current Biden administration's climate policy strategy comparable to the former Trump administration?” The strict dichotomy of their views on climate change affected the stance of the United States in the international sector as a leader of environmental policies. The Paris Agreement has been an important example in the procurement of the different administrations back and forth on their stances on environmental policy.

The Trump Approach:

President Donald Trump’s stance on environmental and climate issues has proven to be somewhat controversial. The former President has gone from decrying climate change as a hoax, orchestrated by the Chinese to weaken the country’s manufacturing sector, to consider himself a true environmentalist who wanted "the cleanest air and the cleanest water" to be a top priority on his administration's political agenda (Worland,2019). Nevertheless, despite being the world’s second largest emitter, the United States appears progressively less willing to be a leader in the fight against climate change. With Trump in office, taking on the entire cost of this leadership is simply not feasible anymore. As a matter of fact, over 100 environmental regulations were rolled back during his presidential term (Popovich et. al, 2021).

The announcement regarding the intention to withdraw from the Paris Agreement was the first sign of this change of course. On June 1, 2017, President Trump announced his decision to pull the country out of the Paris Climate Accord (Trump White House Archives, 2017). “As of today, the United States will cease all implementation of the non-binding Paris Accord and the draconian financial and economic burdens the agreement imposes on our country.” In the logic of America First “the Paris Climate Accord is simply the latest example of Washington entering into an agreement that disadvantages the United States to the exclusive benefit of other countries, leaving American workers […] and taxpayers to absorb the cost in terms of lost jobs, lower wages, shuttered factories, and vastly diminished economic production” (Trump White House Archives, 2017).

On 4 August 2017, the United States’ delegation formally notified the UN of its intention to withdraw from the Paris climate pact “as soon as it is eligible to do so” (UN, 2017). Legally, article 28 of the Agreement states that: At any time after three years from the date on which this Agreement has entered into force for a Party, that Party may withdraw from this Agreement by giving written notification to the Depositary and such withdrawal takes effect upon expiry of one year from the date of receipt by the Depositary of the notification of withdrawal (Paris Agreement, 2015). In practical terms, the Paris Agreement was accepted by the US on 3 September 2016, and it entered into force, in the country, on 4 November 2016. Therefore, regardless of Trump’s intentions, the US Nationally Determined Contribution (NDC), meaning the climate action plan to cut emissions and adapt to climate impacts that each party of the Paris Agreement is required to establish, is set to remain in place until at least 2019 (UN, n.d.). To be more precise, the NDC target established was to reduce net GHG emissions by 26–28% below 2005 levels in 2025 including land use, land use change and forestry (LULUCF).

Throughout its four- years mandate, the Trump Administration has been systematically trying to scramble US federal climate policy. As opposed to the previous administration, President Trump did not announce a comprehensive climate plan. In March 2017, with an Executive Order addressing "energy independence", he simply revoked the Climate Action Plan of the Obama Administration and replaced it with the Affordable Clean Energy rule (EPA, 2021). In a sense, the rollback of previous regulations was intended to spur the use of fossil fuels. This is because a major part of Trump's campaign revolved around his promise to revive the coal industry.

In terms of energy, the administration unleashed America’s oil and natural gas potential. Trump’s determination to increase the United States' energy security has allowed the country to become the world's largest oil producer, while maintaining America's position as the world's largest gas producer. Among the main accomplishments, Trump approved the Keystone XL and Dakota Access pipelines; he opened up the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR) in Alaska to oil and gas leasing; he reformed permitting rules to eliminate unnecessary bureaucracy and speed approval for mines; he supported unrestricted fracking; he has made the average American family save $2,500 a year in lower electric bills and lower prices at the gas pump; he increased LNG exports with the aim to reducing the American trade deficit by over $10 billion, thus providing tens of thousands of jobs; also the amount of nuclear energy production in 2019 was the highest on record. (Trump White House Archives, 2020).

With regard to green investments, the administration argues that renewable energy production and consumption both reached record highs in 2019 due to the enacting policies that increased the amount of wind generation and electricity generated by solar. Further, to protect the environment and ensure clean air and water, “strong” steps were taken. Indeed, Trump’s establishment regarded water quality around the world as a more serious threat than climate change. Therefore, an investment plan of over $38 billion in clean water infrastructure has been approved. (Trump White House Archives, 2020).

Despite withdrawing from the Paris Agreement, the White House has estimated that in 2019 the United States will have achieved the largest decline in carbon emissions of any country on Earth. (Trump White House Archives, 2020). Certainly, in 2020, lockdown in wake of COVID-19 resulted in a significant reduction of US emissions. However, the Trump Administration's continued reversal of climate policies and its response to the pandemic counterbalanced a significant part of this reduction. Unlike his European counterparts, President Trump has not pushed for a green recovery. Rather than addressing the issue, he has exploited the pandemic as a pretext to weaken environmental regulations even more. Democrats' initial stimulus package proposals included direct support for clean energy development, such as investments in green infrastructure. They encouraged the federal tax credit for wind and solar power to be extended. Ultimately, they proposed that airlines set emissions reduction targets before applying for stimulus funds. Conversely, the Republican recovery stimulus plans included USD 3 billion in oil purchases to boost the country's petroleum reserves and further develop the oil industry (CAT, 2020).

Overall, based on the Trump administration’s pledge in the environmental and climate fields, throughout the entire four-year term, the Climate Action Tracker (CAT) rated the US action and commitment as "critically insufficient" (CAT,2020).

The Biden Approach:

A strong opposition with Trump’s environmental policy was always a clear part of Biden’s electoral campaign. As a matter of fact, Biden is determined to reverse Trump’s policy and make America green again. We will now proceed to analyze if and to what extent the new administration acted in order to achieve its environmental goals.

During his very first week in office, Biden kept his promises and signed 17 executive orders, thus immediately dismantling his predecessor’s misdoing. The most requested action was re-entering the Paris Agreement, from which the US had formally withdrawn in 2020. Not only was this Biden’s first action in the fight against climate change, but it was made on his first day in office, which sends a strong message of the new administration’s commitment in terms of environmental protection. What is more, he aims to restore the credibility and prestige of the scientific community: as a matter of fact, following strong criticism by experts and the public opinion, he adapted his environmental plan and set more ambitious objectives.

Biden also took part in the COP26 (October 2021) and set a new objective in terms of CO2 emissions: he aims to reach net zero by 2050. In several sectors, he also set new environmental standards, for instance on the emission of greenhouse gases, air quality and toxic chemicals.

Concerning the energy sector, among the most relevant measures stand the introduction of a tax plan to wind back fossil fuel subsidies in favor of incentives to green energy. To this end, the administration increased the budget for research in the energetic sector by 30%.

However, Biden’s environmental policy is not based on an abstract ideal: with the ‘green transition’ he aims to create 1 million green and “well-paying” jobs. The sectors concerned are mainly green building, the transition to renewable energy, agriculture (an activity with high carbon-intensity) and transports.

But how to reach these objectives? Among other things, such as the speeding up and simplification of environmental procedures, the Biden administration is working on new environmental legislation, be it through the revision of existing Acts, their enforcement or through the adoption of new laws. In particular, two significant legislative instruments were proposed: the Build Back Better Act (‘BBBA’) and the Infrastructure, Investments and Jobs Act (‘IIJA’).

While the BBBA has not yet been adopted by Congress, the IIJA was approved on 6 November 2021. It includes provisions on public transit, environmental projects, water storage, electric vehicles (‘EV’) and the transition to renewable energy for power infrastructure. The Act provides for the largest investment in clean energy transmission and grid in American history, with an investment of $65 billion.

To begin with, the Act aims at increasing energy efficiency, an objective that the US have in common with several other countries. As a matter of fact, greater energy efficiency means obtaining better energetic performance by a lesser expenditure of resources, and would thus lower carbon emissions.

Biden’s policies are also touching US landscapes and habitats in a more concrete way. In particular, the new president stopped pipelines projects and the drilling activities of the Keystone XL pipeline in the Arctic Natural Wildlife Refuge. This measure will contribute to the preservation of a delicate American habitat as well as the transition towards a greener energy mix. To this respect, Biden aims to have 30% of federal land and water protected and to tackle some pending issues, such as that of the Convention on Biological Diversity.

As for infrastructure, the Act aims to “repair and rebuild our roads and bridges with a focus on climate change mitigation, resilience, equity, and safety for all users”, as well as to create a full network of EV chargers and improve airports and ports.

Moving from habitats to wildlife, it is worth mentioning the revision of the Endangered Species Act, to counter the modifications made by former president Trump. Indeed, while Trump had considerably reduced the number of protected species, Biden reintroduced most of them into the category of ‘endangered species’ and even added some other species to the list. Given the strong link between the environment and wildlife (animals and plants are part of habitats and ecosystems, and the latter would not exist as such without the former), this measure can be considered as an important step toward environmental preservation.

Furthermore, through the Executive Order 14008, on 27 January 2021 Biden created a new advisory body, the “White House Environmental Justice Advisory Council” (WHEJAC), “to advise the Chair of the Council of Environmental Quality (CEQ) and the newly established White House Environmental Justice Interagency Council (IAC)”. This initiative shows the political will to strengthen the link between the scientific community and environmental policies. The implication of experts in the policy-making process is the key to successful measures, especially if we consider the highly technical level of the new environmental legislation.

However, despite Biden’s real efforts and all the measures taken, the reversion process is still far from being completed. According to a research published by Berkley University, as to May 2021 42% of Trump’s moot policies are still left unaddressed, delayed or kept under review (Barnosky et al, 2021). Also, some delicate issues, such as gas and pipelines, were not fully tackled. The good news is that he prioritized urgent and high-impact actions, which compensates the relatively low percentage of achievement. The agencies which were most targeted were the EPA (Environmental Protection Agency), the DOI (Department of Interior), and the DOE (Department of Energy).

It is still early to assess Biden’s environmental policy. The political will to act quickly and decidedly is undisputed. However, it may not be enough: policies must be accurate, effective and fully implemented, despite all political differences and the need for compromise. The following years will show whether Biden’s actions will be able to achieve all its objectives and, above all, whether they will be enough to stop, or at least reduce the impact of, climate change.

Authors: Erika Trotta, Valentina Horlander, Alessandra Colasanti

Acknowledgments:

“All About the NDCs”, Climate Action, United Nations, n.d..

https://www.un.org/en/climatechange/all-about-ndcs

“Country Assessment_USA”, Climate Action Tracker (CAT), Updated November 6, 2017.

https://climateactiontracker.org/media/documents/2018/4/CAT_2017-11-06_CountryAssessment_USA_8fXxIrP.pdf

“Country Assessment_USA”, Climate Action Tracker (CAT), Updated July 30, 2020.

https://climateactiontracker.org/countries/usa/2020-07-30/

“Energy and Environment”, Trump White House Archives, July 30, 2020.

https://trumpwhitehouse.archives.gov/issues/energy-environment/

“Paris Agreement to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change”, Dec. 12, 2015, T.I.A.S. No. 16-1104.

https://unfccc.int/files/meetings/paris_nov_2015/application/pdf/paris_agreement_english_.pdf

Popovich, N. et al., “The Trump Administration Rolled Back More Than 100 Environmental Rules. Here’s the Full List”, The New York Times, Updated January 20,2021. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/climate/trump-environment-rollbacks-list.html

“Proposal: Affordable Clean Energy (ACE) Rule”, United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), 2021

https://www.epa.gov/stationary-sources-air-pollution/proposal-affordable-clean-energy-ace-rule#:~:text=On%20August%2021%2C%202018%2C%20the,existing%20coal%2Dfired%20power%20plants.

“Statement by President Trump on the Paris Climate Accord”, in Energy and Environment, Trump White House Archives, June 1, 2017.

https://trumpwhitehouse.archives.gov/briefings-statements/statement-president-trump-paris-climate-accord/

“UN officially notified of US intention to withdraw from Paris climate pact”, UN News, United Nations, August 4, 2017.

https://news.un.org/en/story/2017/08/562872-un-officially-notified-us-intention-withdraw-paris-climate-pact

Worland, J., “Donald Trump Called Climate Change a Hoax. Now He's Awkwardly Boasting About Fighting It”, Time, July 8, 2019.

https://time.com/5622374/donald-trump-climate-change-hoax-event/

RepublicanViews.org. “Republican Views on the Environment: Republican Views.” |, 3 Feb. 2018, https://www.republicanviews.org/republican-views-on-the-environment/

Barnosky, Clara; Sadler Jane; Yates Richard; Zimmerman, Zachary, “Reversing Trump Environmental Rollbacks: A 100 Day Analysis on the Biden Administration’s Reversals”, https://www.law.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/Trump-Rollbacks-Report.pdf

Bradner, Eric; Klein, Betsy; Hickey, Christopher, “Biden targets Trump's legacy with first-day executive actions”, CNN, https://edition.cnn.com/2021/01/20/politics/executive-actions-biden/index.html

Congress.com, H.R.3684 - Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, https://www.congress.gov/bill/117th-congress/house-bill/3684/text

Davenport, Coral, “Restoring Environmental Rules Rolled Back by Trump Could Take Years”, The New York Times, 22 January 2021, https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/22/climate/biden-environment.html

Eilperin, Juliet; Dennis, Brady and Muyskens, John, “Tracking Biden’s environmental actions”, The Washington Post, 17 March 2022, https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2021/climate-environment/biden-climate-environment-actions/

EPA, “White House Environmental Justice Advisory Council”, https://www.epa.gov/environmentaljustice/white-house-environmental-justice-advisory-council

Joebiden.com, “Climate: 10 million clean energy jobs”, https://joebiden.com/climate-labor-fact-sheet/

Joebiden.com, “The Biden plan for a clean energy revolution and environmental justice”, https://joebiden.com/climate-plan/

Milman, Oliver and Chang Alvin, “How Biden is reversing Trump's assault on the environment”, The Guardian, 2 February 2021, https://theguardian.com/us-news/2021/feb/02/biden-trump-environment-climate-crisis

Whitehouse.gov, “Executive Order on Protecting Public Health and the Environment and Restoring Science to Tackle the Climate Crisis”, https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/presidential-actions/2021/01/20/executive-order-protecting-public-health-and-environment-and-restoring-science-to-tackle-climate-crisis/

Whitehouse.gov, “FACT SHEET: President Biden Takes Executive Actions to Tackle the Climate Crisis at Home and Abroad, Create Jobs, and Restore Scientific Integrity Across Federal Government”, 27 January, 2021, https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2021/01/27/fact-sheet-president-biden-takes-executive-actions-to-tackle-the-climate-crisis-at-home-and-abroad-create-jobs-and-restore-scientific-integrity-across-federal-government/

Whitehouse.gov, “Fact Sheet: The Bipartisan Infrastructure Deal”, https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2021/11/06/fact-sheet-the-bipartisan-infrastructure-deal/

Share the post