Abstract:
The elections that were held in the United States on November 8th, 2022 can be considered as a mirror of some important patterns in American politics and society. Their results, unclear until some days after the event, made it clear that American voters are still coping with former President Trump’s political inheritance. On the one hand, the Republican Party gained some important seats in both the Houses, winning the majority in the House of Representatives. On the other hand, the Party’s position was significantly weakened by some recent facts, such as the abolition of Roe v. Wade decision at the Supreme Court. The paper analyses gains and losses of both the parties in all the dimensions of the vote - House and Senate, Governors, state officers, propositions and amendments.
Authors:
Matteo Bulzomì - Senior Researcher, Mondo Internazionale G.E.O. - Politics
Nicola Zanini - Junior Researcher, Mondo Internazionale G.E.O. - Politics
Introduction
On November 8th, 2022, the United States of America hosted an important electoral round. Despite being extensively addressed as “midterm elections”, the November 8th elections saw the U.S. citizens voting for all the seats of the House of Representatives, around a third of the seats of the Senate, thirty-six governors and state officers, and a number of state-level issues, propositions and amendments.
- American Constitutional System
The constitutional system of the United States is one of the most ancient still in function. It was engineered at the end of the 18th century in order to solve a range of issues that affected the newly-born country. Back then, the country’s founding fathers were mainly cultured, white, protestant landowners who shared strong pro-republic and anti-democratic views. On the one hand, the Republic was deemed to be the most functional form of government because it would prevent the concentration of power in the hand of a single person. On the other hand, they thought that democracy was not less dangerous than a monarchy, because it was based on the rule of the masses. Given that the masses were not educated and had no time to dedicate to public affairs, they had to be prevented as much as possible from being able to set up the state’s agenda (Mekouar, 2021). Indeed, only property-owning and educated men were granted the right to vote in the first decades of the country’s history. As time went by, such anti-democratic aspects were gradually weakened, albeit not totally cancelled. For instance, the criteria for granting people their right to vote are still decided upon at a state level rather than the federal level.
The main crux of the U.S. constitutional system is the so-called “Checks and Balances” system (Cornell Law School). Itself a product of the republican and anti-democratic mentality of the founding fathers, the Checks and Balances system is based on the separation and balance of the three constitutional powers: legislative, executive, and judicial branches. The legislative power is embodied by the U.S. Congress, which in turn is divided into two branches: the House of Representatives and the Senate. The choice of an (almost) perfect bicameralism was itself inspired by the principle of Checks and Balances. Indeed, it was conceived as a way to further dilute the power in the hands of the legislative branch. Besides passing pieces of legislation, the Congress exerts a certain control on the other two powers. Indeed, it may limit the power of the executive by impeaching the President and refusing to pass the federal budget law. Furthermore, it has the power to impeach federal judges. However, an impeachment procedure can be started only for criminal actions and not for political reasons.
The executive power, meanwhile, is in the hands of the President of the United States, who approves the laws passed by the Congress and appoints the judges of the Supreme Court. Because the President is elected almost directly by the U.S. citizens, they cannot be removed from power by the other two powers unless in case of impeachment.
Finally, the judicial power supervises the constitutionality of both the President and the Congress’ acts. Whereas the members of the Supreme Court are nominated by the executive power, the President and the Congress members are elected by the people. The President of the United States is elected every four years and cannot serve more than twice in a row. As for the members of the Congress, the Senators enjoy a six-year-mandate, whereas the members of the House of Representatives serve a two-year term. Every two years, roughly one-third of the Congress’ members are elected by the people (Onque, 2022).
- The road to November 8th, 2022
The November 8th elections came in the middle of a turbulent period that is shaking the U.S. and the world. In particular, the deep political clashes that interested U.S. public opinion especially after the 2020 Presidential elections affected both the political and the institutional life. In the political arena, the main issue was handling the vexatious inheritance of the former Republican President Donald J. Trump. Trump’s first, and so far only, term created important issues within the Republican Party and the Democratic Party alike. Ever since the beginning of Trump’s political career with the Republicans, a number of Republican politicians and voters decided not to support him due to his inflammatory vision of America. As for the Democratic Party, its main concern was that Trump’s vision of the world, albeit very controversial, did gain him the support from large fringes of U.S. voters.
The situation further degenerated between November 3rd, 2020 and January 6th, 2021. In this relatively small time frame, Donald Trump lost the presidential elections but refused to concede the victory to his opponent, the Democratic candidate Joseph R. Biden. On January 6th, a mob of Trump supporters tried to storm the Capitol, seat of the Congress, which was then overseeing Biden’s accession to the Presidency. Trump’s role in those events is controversial. On the one hand, he did not personally take part in the event; on the other hand, his will not to recognize the outcome of the elections played a key role in pushing his most devoted supporters to march on Capitol Hill. After those disgraceful events, an unsuccessful impeachment process was started in order to clarify Trump’s role and possibly prevent him from running for a second term in 2024.
The impeachment process amplified the internal divisions within the Republican Caucus. A number of high-level party members such as Liz Cheney, Mitt Romney, and Susan Collins continuously requested that the party cut its ties with Trump. However, a remarkable part of the Republican Party is still supporting the former President. After Trump was acquitted in the trial, such an intra-party division turned into an open war between pro-Trump and anti-Trump Republicans. In this view, the November 8th elections were perceived as the ultimate showdown between the factions. The consequences of such division became visible some weeks later, when the Speaker of the House was confirmed (see part 3) (Axelrod, 2022).
The fractures within the Republican Party had important consequences on the political strategy of the Democrats as well. Indeed, the Democratic party’s leadership was divided on whether to support the anti-Trump faction of the Republican party, running the risk of losing the elections or to take advantage of this division. Both paths carried advantages and disadvantages. If they chose to support the anti-Trump Republicans, the Democrats would protect the American political arena from the influence of anti-democracy leaders, while risking losing the elections. On the other hand, weakening the Republicans would bring about substantial political advantages, while strengthening anti-democracy leaders (Linskey, 2022).
Ever since the beginning of his term, President Biden had to deal with many important crises such as the Covid-19 pandemic, roaring inflation, political violence, and the Ukrainian crisis. The way he addressed such issues left many U.S. citizens unsatisfied. Together with Trump’s will to pave his way to a re-election in 2024, this sentiment fuelled the feeling that the Republicans would achieve a significant victory in the November 8th elections. Even though the polling agencies had always maintained a pretty cautious attitude, the so-called “red wave” was considered to be one of the most likely scenarios (Waxman, 2022).
Ironically, the Democrats were aided by a mostly conservative institution: the Supreme Court. Indeed, the decision to overturn the famous Roe v Wade sentence, which granted the right to abortion, had a tremendous effect on the voting decisions (Alter, 2022). Voters coming from both Democratic and Republican backgrounds feared that the civil rights sphere would suffer from further erosion should the Republicans - and especially the pro-Trump candidates - win the November 8th vote. As a consequence, the anti-Trump (and, to some extent, anti-Republican) front gained momentum from the actions of six Republican judges, rather than from the ability of the whole Democratic leadership.
- The house races.
As already mentioned, every two years, more than 200 million Americans from across the country are called to the polls to renew all of the 435 seats of the House of Representatives. Since 1994, every President has lost at least one of the two houses during the midterms. This has therefore weakened the commander-in-chiefs’ ability to swiftly pass reforms and programmes, on both sides of the aisle. This happens because, since these elections usually take place in the middle of a Presidential term, they are often seen as a sort of referendum on the President's work. If they have not brought forward the agenda they campaigned on, or were not able to face the day-to-day issues that Americans are faced with swiftly, the citizens usually vote to express their disapproval.
All throughout 2022, in the majority of polls conducted in the US, there was the distinct possibility of a so-called “red wave”, meaning that the Republican party was projected to win the vast majority of seats in the House of Representatives, reaching, at its maximum, in June 2022, a projected majority of 238 seats out of 435. Even though this number had fallen in the following months, up until the day of the elections, they were still projected to have a significant margin over the Democratic party (FiveThirtyEight, 2022). These polls reflected, in fact, the socio-political situation in the country. At the time of the elections, many were the issues at stake, including the roaring inflation that flagellated not only the country but the world at large. Inflation and the general economic situation were some of the main points of the Republican campaigns, and their candidates put the strategies of President Biden at the forefront of their races, exploiting the main issues for families, i.e. the increase in the price of essential goods and gas, as well as the traditional capacity of the GOP (“The Great Old Party” way in which the Republican Party is often referred to as) to keep the economy under check.
On the day of the election, therefore, once the Exit polls came in, there was an extreme surprise in knowing that the race was closer than anyone had expected. As the night went on, it appeared clearer that the election would not be called for a long time, due to various factors. The first factor was the difference in voting rules amongst States and among various counties, which regulates the counting of absentee and early-voting ballots differently. Another important factor was the very close margins between the candidates in several districts all throughout the country.
However, it appeared clear that the race would be closer than anyone had projected or wished. Only on November 16th, eight days after the election, were the main news agencies able to project the final result of the elections: 222 seats to the Republicans and 213 for the Democrats (CNN, 2022). A discussion on the reasons behind such a closer-than-expected race thus sparked.
To understand why the success of the Republicans was so narrow, even in an economic and social landscape that had been favourable to the GOP in the past, it is useful to look at the exit polls. These were compiled by the main American news agencies, especially regarding the main issues that were in the minds of the electors in the polling stations. In fact, even though the vast majority of the electors were dissatisfied with the situation in the US, it was not only due to the economy. One of the main aspects that electors considered was abortion. In the light of the Supreme Court decision overturning Roe v. Wade, in fact, it suddenly became a front-and-centre-stage issue (ABC News, 2022). In the country, in fact, the vast majority of the population is in favour of abortion and the Republicans’ campaigning against it has surely hurt their approval, especially in the ranks of the voters who identify with neither of the two main parties and that are the so-called swing voters, due to their ability to effectively decide the elections by ‘swinging’ from one party to another. The former President Trump was also in the minds of the voters (CNN, 2022). In fact, many of the GOP candidates were personally approved by the former President, thanks to their position on the 2020 elections and their refusal to accept the results of those elections. This issue has also hurt the party’s chances. In fact, many long-time Republicans were dismayed by the party’s position and either voted for Independent or Democratic candidates.
The results of the House elections will have several effects on the day-to-day running of the country. First of all, the Republican majority in the House will mean that the President will need to extensively negotiate with the other party’s leadership in order to bring forward its policies and to protect already passed ones, such as Medicaid, Social Security or the financing of the Inflation Reduction Act or the various infrastructure bills.
On the other hand, the very slim majority will make of the Republican House one of the weakest majorities in recent years. This has clearly been shown during the election of the Speaker of the House. GOP House Leader Kevin McCarthy, in fact, needed the majority of cast votes to be elected as Speaker. This procedure, which should have only been a procedural matter, has been transformed into the longest stalemate of the House proceedings in two centuries. This has blocked the normal functioning of the lower chamber for four days and has ended only after 15 votes and countless concessions from the party’s leadership to the most extreme fringe of it, called the Freedom Caucus.
- The Senate Races
On November 8th, Americans were also called to renew 27 seats of the Senate. Before the election, in this chamber, Democrats (including two Independents) and Republicans had equal seats, and thus in the votes of the house, ties were to be ‘split’ (decided) by Vice-President Kamala Harris, as per the provisions of the Constitution. Democrats and Republicans had the clear objective of gaining at least 51 seats, in order to have a majority in the Senate, which would allow the former to pass votes without the intervention of the Vice-President, and would allow the latter to contrast the plans of the Administration.
Like per the House race, in the polls leading to the election, Republicans were favoured to gain control of the Senate, even though with a lower percentage compared to their colleagues in the lower chamber (FiveThirtyEight, 2022). The above-cited issues, however, made it so that in the days following the election, 10 seats were gained by the Democrats and 16 by the Republicans, bringing the partial total to 50 seats for the Democrats and 49 for the Republicans (The Guardian, 2022).
The last seat to be decided was that of Georgia. Due to long-standing laws in the State, a candidate for the Senate has to have 50% plus one of the votes cast, and neither the Democrat Warnock nor the Republican Walker received such a majority. A runoff election would therefore be needed to be held on December 6th, marking the second time in two consecutive years that the Democratic candidate would have faced such an election. Like in the 2021 runoff, the 2022 one saw incumbent Senator Warnock defeat the opponent, thereby earning the Democratic party a 51-seat majority in the Senate for the first time in 10 years.
Even though the Republican party will likely not allow the Democratic party to pass a large number of bills in the House of Representatives,the Democrat majority in the Senate will become an important measure to limit the Republican Agenda. In fact, Democrats will have the possibility to stop any bill passing the House from becoming law, not needing the veto of the President. Moreover, a majority in the Senate will allow Democrats to have the majority in each Senate Committee, allowing them to process legislation and confirm Presidential nominations more quickly. It will, moreover, be possible for the Democrats to fill a possible Supreme Court vacancy more easily.
- Gubernatorial and other races
In the 2022 midterms, as well as in the Congressional elections, thirty-six states were called to re-elect their Governors. Many more states, moreover, were called to the polls to elect state-level officials and to vote upon a host of state-level issues, propositions, and amendments. Out of the thirty-six races, eighteen were won by Republican Candidates, who were often supported by former President Trump, and eighteen were won by Democratic candidates. This brought, therefore, the number of States gubernatorial seats controlled by the GOP to 26 from 31.
At the state-level, the most important races, apart from the Gubernatorial ones, were forthe role of Secretary of State. Such figures are important because, in most States, they are the officers responsible for certifying the Great Electors, who are essential for the rightful election of the US President. Therefore, it is important to understand the candidates who rejected, questioned, or tried to overturn the collected results of the 2020 election. Out of 12 such candidates, only eight won, all in states with a Republican-led legislature and Governor (CNN, 2022).
In order to have an effective view of the political situation of the Country, the results of the ballots and propositions on the ballots are also of great importance. For example, after the decision of the Supreme Court to overturn Roe v. Wade, five states put forward propositions to either protect the right to abortion or abolish it. The results reflected the political position in the country already discussed; in fact, all five states that put forward such proposals have defended the right to abortion.
Another issue in the proposition was the legalisation of drugs and marijuana. Out of five states which proposed the legalisation of marijuana, three did not approve. One important other case was Colorado Proposition 122 proposing the decriminalisation of the possession of certain hallucinogens, which received 53.6% of votes (Politico, 2022).
- Conclusion
Several conclusions can be drawn from the results of the 2022 midterm elections. First of all, the future political scenario of the United States can be forecasted. In particular it will not be possible for either party to pass key elements of legislation without an agreement. This is of extreme importance, not only for extraordinary pieces of legislation, such as the approval of economic recovery plans or for measures to implement safety net programmes, but also for the approval of bills necessary to the normal functioning of the country. One of the pieces of legislation that is most important is the approval of the raising of the debt ceiling or the approval of the federal budget. The polarisation of American politics on this topic has created an environment in which it will be extremely difficult to manoeuvre, especially after the concessions that Speaker McCarthy made in order to be elected to the office. Moreover, from the exit polls, it is clear that former President Trump's approval has declined and the majority of voters, even those that had believed his claims on the 2020 elections, have been disillusioned (ABC news). This raises the question of who will be the Republican candidate to the presidency in 2024, seeing the fact that Trump has already put forward his candidacy and that no apparent runner-up has presented theirs.
Classification of sources and information:
1 | Confirmed | Confirmed by other independent sources; logical in itself; coherent with other information on the topic |
2 | Presumably true | Not confirmed; logical in itself; coherent with other information on the topic |
3 | Maybe true | Not confirmed; reasonably logical in itself; coherent with some other information on the topic |
4 | Uncertain | Not confirmed; possible but not logical in itself; no other information on the topic |
5 | Improbable | Not confirmed; not logical in itself; contradicts with other information on the topic |
6 | Not able to be evaluated | No basis to evaluate the validity of the information |
Trustworthiness of the source | ||
A | Trustworthy | No doubt about authenticity, reliability or competence; has a history of total trustworthiness |
B | Normally trustworthy | Small doubts about authenticity, reliability or competence, nevertheless has a history of valid information in a majority of cases |
C | Sufficiently trustworthy | Doubts about authenticity, reliability or competence; however, has supplied valid information in the past |
D | Normally not trustworthy | Significant doubt about authenticity, reliability or competence, however has supplied valid information in the past |
E | Not trustworthy | Lack of authenticity, reliability or competence; history of invalid information |
F | Not able to be evaluated | No basis to evaluate the validity of the information |
Sources:
- “2022 House Election Forecast”, FiveThirtyEight, 8 November 2022, https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/2022-election-forecast/house/ (B-1)
- “2022 Senate Election Forecast”, FiveThirtyEight, 8 November 2022, https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/2022-election-forecast/senate/ (B-1)
- C. Alter, “How Abortion Helped Blunt a Red Wave in the Midterms”, Time, 9 November 2022, https://time.com/6231550/how-abortion-helped-blunt-a-red-wave-in-the-midterms/ (B-2)
- T. Axelrod, “What can the not-Trumo Republicans accomplish?”, abc News, 31 August 2022, https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/trump-republicans-accomplish/story?id=88816890 (B-2)
- “Ballot Measures”, CNN Politics, 30 December 2022, https://edition.cnn.com/election/2022/results/ballot-measures (B-1)
- T. Barrett, A. Zaslav, “What a 51-49 Senate Majority means for Democrats”, CNN Politics, 7 December 2022, https://edition.cnn.com/2022/12/06/politics/senate-democrats-majority-advantages/index.html (B-2)
- C. Bleiker, “US midterms: 5 key races to watch”, Deutsche Welle, 11 August 2022, https://www.dw.com/en/us-midterms-5-key-house-senate-and-gubernatorial-races/a-63578092 (B-2)
- S. Collinson, “Republicans will win the House, CNN projects”, CNN Politics, 16 November 2022, https://edition.cnn.com/2022/11/16/politics/republicans-win-house-of-representatives/index.html (B-2)
- “Exit Polls 2022”, NBC news, 29 December 2022, https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/2022-elections/exit-polls (B-1)
- “House of Representatives: Election Results”, Washington Post, 18 December 2022, https://www.washingtonpost.com/election-results/2022/house/ (B-1)
- “House of Representatives Results: GOP Wins the Majority”, CNN politics, 18 December 2022, https://edition.cnn.com/election/2022/results/house?election-data-id=2022-HG&election-painting-mode=projection&filter-key-races=false&filter-flipped=false (B-1)
- “Key Ballot Measures and Referendums”, Politico, 12 January 2023, https://www.politico.com/2022-election/results/ballot-measures/ (B-1)
- A. Linskey, “Democrats spend tens of millions amplifying far-right candidates in nine states”, The Washington Post, 12 September 2022, https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/09/12/democrats-interfere-republican-primaries/ (C-2)
- “Midterm elections results: This is where the races stand”, BBC, 12 November 2022, https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-63586485 (B-1)
- D. Mekouar, “Today’s Democracy Isn't' Exactly What Wealthy US Founding Fathers Envisioned”, VoA News, 24 January 2021, https://www.voanews.com/a/usa_all-about-america_todays-democracy-isnt-exactly-what-wealthy-us-founding-fathers-envisioned/6201097.html (B-1)
- D. Merkle, “What you need to know about Election Day Exit Polls”, ABC News, 8 November 2022, https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/election-day-exit-polls/story?id=73792952 (B-1)
- “National Exit Poll: House”, ABC news, 8 November 2022, https://abcnews.go.com/Elections/exit-polls-2022-us-house-election-results-analysis (B-1)
- R. Onque, “50% of voters say the overturning of Roe v. Wade makes them more eager to vote in this year’s midterm election”, CNBC, 3 November 2022, https://www.cnbc.com/2022/11/03/survey-50percent-of-voters-say-roe-v-wade-is-encouraging-them-to-vote.html (B-1)
- “Secretary of State Results”, CNN Politics, 30 December 2022, https://edition.cnn.com/election/2022/results/secretary-of-state?election-data-id=2022-SSG&election-painting-mode=projection&filter-key-races=false&filter-flipped=false (B-1)
- “Separation of Powers”, Cornell Law School, https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/separation_of_powers_0 (B-1)
- C. Trainor, T. Hartman, A. J. Levine, “Charting the Midterms. The main takeaways of the 2022 midterm elections, visualized”, Reuters, 9 November 2022, https://www.reuters.com/graphics/USA-ELECTION/MIDTERMS/zgpobwokdvd/index.html (B-2)
- A. Voce, S. Clarke, N. de Hoog, A. Leach, “US midterm elections results 2022: live”, 15 November 2022, https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2022/nov/15/house-election-results-2022-live-senate-us-midterm-state-map-latest-winners-congress (B-2)
- O. Waxman, “The 2022 Midterm Wasn’t a Wave Election. Here’s Where It Fits in History, So Far”, Time (B-2)