Translated by Maria Pia Longo
Who Has the Right to Be Heard?
The protests that have been sweeping through French high schools for weeks raise a question that goes beyond education: who has the right to be considered a legitimate voice in public debate? Student representatives argue that the executive branch treats them as subjects to be managed rather than as citizens to be heard. The spokesperson for the Union Étudiante, Sabrine Kharbach, accused the government of viewing young people as incapable of understanding budget issues. According to her, however, students understand all too well what it means to allocate massive resources to rearmament while classrooms remain overcrowded. The comparison with the €413.3 billion allocated to the armed forces for the 2024–2030 period is a precise political argument, not emotional naivety. Dismissing it as such is itself a form of underestimation.
Are Responses Matching Demands?
The gap between the seriousness of the demands and the scale of the government's response reinforces this perception. Reports in the press highlight a stark disparity: of the 3,000 substitute teachers announced for priority schools, only 35 percent have actually been deployed, and the 1.6 percent funding increase remains below the estimated inflation rate of 1.8 percent. Compounding this is the weight of law enforcement measures: nearly 7,000 arrests—mostly of minors—and numerous injuries among students. For a generation asking to be heard, receiving a law-and-order response can feel like confirmation that they are viewed as a security problem rather than a political voice.
What Does Politics Risk by Ignoring Youth?
There is also a structural dimension regarding trust in public institutions. Presidential candidate Nicolas Dupont-Aignan, though coming from a position distant from the left, mentioned meeting protesters who were either unregistered on voter lists or lacked faith in voting. The street becomes the most immediate venue for expression when democratic participation feels ineffective; ignoring it risks pushing young people toward more radical forms of representation. Analysts observe that this discontent does not benefit a single political force: while the radical left is gaining support among young voters, Marine Le Pen continues to score well among 18-to-24-year-olds, whereas centrist candidates appear disconnected from the protest movement. For a political sphere aspiring to govern from the center, alienating younger generations presents a tangible risk.
Do Government Justifications Suffice?
Prime Minister Lecornu acknowledged that behind the unrest lies genuine anxiety that must be addressed with humility; he launched a national consultation aimed at students and maintained that budget constraints, in a country carrying one of the eurozone's highest deficits, necessitate a gradual approach. The government further claims to have instructed law enforcement to act with proportionality and emphasizes that clashes have also left approximately 800 police officers and school staff injured. The decisive question thus remains open: whether these initiatives will yield tangible changes or be perceived merely as token gestures. The answer will determine not only the longevity of the movement, but also the credibility of a political class called upon to prove that listening to young people means taking them seriously.
Mondo Internazionale APS - All Rights Reserved - 2026