The Evolution of Relations Between the Vatican and Latin America

  Articoli (Articles)
  Beatrice Parisi
  03 October 2026
  6 minutes, 43 seconds

Translated by Benedetta Calice


In the Latin American region, the Vatican has sought to adapt its presence in response to social needs, so much so that evangelization activities have often taken on a deeply social meaning. Although in different forms, inequalities have always characterized the anatomy of Latin America, sometimes making political mediation necessary and, in other cases, forms of social protection and moral defence. Therefore, the Holy See's influence in Latin America is a deeply rooted phenomenon, although it has not manifested itself uniformly over the centuries.

During the colonial period, it was the Iberian monarchies that played a central role in managing ecclesiastical affairs. This system was known as royal patronage (patronato regio) and granted the Spanish and Portuguese crowns broad powers over the organization of the Church in colonial territories. Relations between local churches and Rome were heavily mediated by monarchical power, within an organizational system that was far from centralized. The establishment of the royal patronage system reduced the Vatican's organizational role; thus, the Holy See's presence was adapted with a strong social meaning, with many missionaries taking a stance of critical activism in defence of indigenous populations against colonizers, which allowed the Holy See to promote its social role.

After the colonies gained independence, the royal patronage exercised by the Spanish and Portuguese monarchies gradually faded away; at the same time, the Holy See sought to build a more direct relationship with the new Latin American political and ecclesiastical realities. In 1858, the establishment of this new relationship reached a significant milestone with the founding of the Pontifical Latin American College in Rome. The institution contributed to strengthening the ties between local churches and the Holy See, as the training offered to Latin American priests was intended to foster a universal perspective of the Catholic Church.

The Holy See's social role continued to be evident, especially as society began to confront the initial processes of modernization and urbanization, which led to inequalities that gradually took on an increasingly broader scope. However, with the establishment of dictatorial regimes in the region, a discrepancy was observed between the official position of the Holy See and the stance of local ecclesiastical institutions toward the new political reality. Indeed, the establishment of military regimes in several countries in the region confronted local churches with the problem of their relationship with repressive governments. The response of local ecclesiastical hierarchies was not uniform, and the phenomenon of dictatorship was addressed differently in various national contexts, creating tension with the official position of the Holy See. The experiences gained in Argentina and Chile are particularly representative of the differences that characterized the local churches' stance toward dictatorial regimes, highlighting how, in the face of the same context of repression, deeply different modes of intervention could emerge.

In Argentina, a section of the ecclesiastical leadership maintained collaborative and close relations with the military authorities, such as in the case of Adolfo Tortolo - then president of the episcopal conference, known for his conservative positions. At the same time, other Argentine ecclesiastical figures, though in the minority, opposed the regime. Opposition to repressive regimes was also part of the Holy See's official position: Paul VI himself expressed concern to the Argentine ambassador over the violence perpetrated by the regime and publicly called several times for the necessity of respecting fundamental human rights.

The mobilization that developed in Chile was different in some respects, where components of the local church took an active role in protecting the victims of repression. Legal, economic, and social assistance to victims and their families was not only a demonstration of the church's further social commitment but also contributed to documenting human rights violations committed by dictatorial regimes.

Despite the different approaches pursued by local ecclesiastical entities, a common thread can be observed in the Holy See's activity: the recourse to a form of influence that, rather than relying exclusively on the instruments of diplomacy, was exercised through the moral authority of the Pope. In 1976, the International Theological Commission published a document titled "Human Promotion and Christian Salvation", in which it also addressed the relationship between the Church and contemporary political and social transformations, with particular attention to Latin America. The document affirms that politics cannot assume an absolute value and that the Church has a duty to oppose the dictatorial claims of a State that intends to exclusively control all dimensions of social life.

Following the collapse of dictatorial regimes, the pontificate of John Paul II closely followed the socio-political transformations of Latin America. While continuing to use traditional instruments of bilateral and multilateral diplomacy, the Vatican developed a broader public action aimed at accompanying political transitions and fostering the consolidation of new democratic frameworks. Thus, Vatican diplomacy added the protection of religious freedom and relations with new Latin American political systems to its priorities. This diplomatic dimension was accompanied by the direct intervention of John Paul II, whose moral authority allowed the Holy See to address not only governments but also civil society and local ecclesiastical institutions. Through apostolic journeys, public speeches, and interventions addressed to political authorities, the Pontiff intervened on the main issues of Latin American transitions, recalling the value of democracy, respect for human rights, religious freedom, and reconciliation.

Despite the spread of religious pluralism and the growing competition from evangelical churches, the years of John Paul II's pontificate also represented a period of particular vitality for Catholicism. Indeed, Pope Wojtyła's political action contributed to keeping the Catholic Church at the centre of social and political debate, thanks to his ability to present the Church as a partner in ongoing transformations. The political strength of Pope John Paul II's pontificate became evident during the mediation of the territorial dispute between Argentina and Chile over the southern region and the Beagle Channel. The mediation lasted for several years and led to the direct involvement of the Pope. This episode represents a significant example of the diplomatic dimension of the Holy See's influence in the region: the Vatican acted not only as a religious authority, but as a diplomatic entity recognized by the parties and capable of intervening in the resolution of an international dispute.

It is within the context of the gradual decline of Catholic identification that the pontificates of Francis and Leo XIV are situated. Rather than representing a reversal of the process of Catholic decline in the region, they can be interpreted as an attempt to renew the forms of Catholic presence in Latin American society. Francis, the first Latin American pontiff, placed the peripheries, poverty, inequality, and human dignity at the centre of his pontificate, strengthening the social dimension of his Church.

Leo XIV, whose pontificate is still too recent to allow an assessment of its effects on religious practice and affiliation, appears to move in continuity with the desire to give new vitality to Catholicism in Latin America, especially in light of his long pastoral experience in Peru and the special attention paid to poverty and social justice. In this sense, the last two pontificates do not seem to mark a return to Catholicism's previous centrality so much as the search for new ways through which the Church attempts to maintain its relevance in increasingly pluralistic societies. The attempt at a relaunch primarily concerns the public, social, and cultural presence of Catholicism: in the face of losing numerical centrality, the Holy See seems to be betting on its ability to offer a response to major social issues and to maintain a dialogue role in Latin America.

Mondo
Internazionale APS - Riproduzione Riservata - 2026

Share the post

L'Autore

Beatrice Parisi

Categories

South America

Tag

America Latina vaticano chiesa cattolica